Winston Churchill Lugo Aff
| Tournament | Round | Opponent | Judge | Cites | Round Report | Open Source | Edit/Delete |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colleyville | 1 | idk | idk |
|
| ||
| Grapevine | 2 | St Johns AW | Marilyn Myrick |
|
| ||
| Greenhill | Round 1 | Klein Oak AG | Mute Nintunze |
|
|
| |
| Greenhill | Round 1 | Klein Oak AG | Mute Nintunze |
|
|
| |
| Greenhill | 1 | Klein Oak AG |
|
| |||
| Greenhill | 1 | Klein Oak AG |
|
| |||
| St Marks | 3 | good question | Jonathan Horowitz |
|
| ||
| St Marks | 3 | idk | Jonathan Horowitz |
|
| ||
| St Marks | 3 | idk | Jonathan Horowitz |
|
| ||
| gbx | 1 | good question | good question |
|
|
| Tournament | Round | Report |
|---|---|---|
| Greenhill | Round 1 | Opponent: Klein Oak AG | Judge: Mute Nintunze 1NC: |
| Greenhill | Round 1 | Opponent: Klein Oak AG | Judge: Mute Nintunze 1NC: |
To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.
Cites
| Entry | Date |
|---|---|
Borderlands AffTournament: gbx | Round: 1 | Opponent: good question | Judge: good question Part One is La Frontera:The borderlands are defined by the rigid barriers that we impose on people of the strict categorization of ethnicity, race, class, gender that serve as the structure for various forms of oppression. Not only are the borderlands defined by the modes of thinking we have in the status quo but also the geographic spaces we have.Tamdgidi 08Mohammad H. Tamdgidi, Prof. @ U. Mass-Boston, "I Change Myself, I Change the World": Gloria Anzaldua's Sociological Imagination in Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza", Humanity and Society, 2008, p. JSTOR Breaking down the borderlands is key in order for Latinx youth to challenge their own identities and positions in society and lead to real world change.Salazar-Jerez and Fránquiz "Although decades ago the U.S. Census Bureau began forecasting that Latin@s would become the largest minority group in the United States of America, in 2005 ordinary citizens were surprised to learn this projection had become a reality. For some, the reality that Latin@s comprised 13 of the U.S. population (Pew Hispanic Center, 2005) was a hard fact to swallow. The additional prediction from the U.S. Census Bureau ~predicts~ that by the year 2050, Latin~x~@s will comprise approximately 25 of the U.S. population (U.S. Census Bureau, 2004) presents an even more difficult fact for intake. As researchers it is baffling to note that many school districts ignore these demographic changes until families come knocking on school office doors. The realization of Latin~x~@s becoming a significant student population in urban, suburban and rural U.S. schools is a demographic change mandate~es~ing that legislators, policy makers, educators ~to~ and ordinary citizens examine stereotypic information regarding how to best educate a social group who, by all accounts, will continue its very rapid rate of growth (Chapa and De La Rosa, 2004). While in the past, addressing the educational needs of Latin@ youth was conceived within deficit standpoints of who they are as a monolithic bloc and how they threaten both the future of the English language and U.S. resources, research finds that most Latin@ youth are born in the U.S., and prefer to speak and read English (Zentella, 2005). Additionally, these youth are growing up in order to work in the technical, sales, and administrative support sectors (Chapa and De La Rosa, 2004) of 21st century America. They live productive lives in families whose buying power is growing at impressive rates. Thus, we argue that the education of adolescents living in the current demographic reality cannot be addressed with deficit orientations accepted in the past. Instead, we argue that in U.S. schools experiencing "the Browning of America" (Aponte and Siles, 1994; Johnson, et.al. 1997) students must be approached with affirming orientations. These approaches must effectively address Latin~x~@ students' educational struggles as they cross a myriad of borders on a daily basis in order to remain engaged in schools."==Part two: El Problema== ====Meet US citizen and latinx adolescent Juan Mendez who was shot to death by border patrol agent Taylor Poitevent for allegedly being an illegal alien. ==== This very border patrol agent was later granted qualified immunity. Qualified immunity functions in order for governmental authorities to maintain their position in society and value their lives over other unarmed citizens. The discourse of this court case presents the image of Latinx lives as being lesser than that of a border patrol agent—it was either Poitevants life of Mendez's and somehow we allow the normalization of murder to protect the law even if no real threat or law had been broken."UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS." International Legal Materials 20.3 (1981): 650-53. Web A similar struggle confronts people that aren't US citizens but are killed by border patrol—without having the citizen rights that Americans do, there is little justice for those with violence imposed on them. Sergio Hernandez, a Mexican citizen was playing with friends in Ciduad Juarez when shot to death by Officer Jesus Mesa who was on the US side of the border in El Paso, Texas. The supreme court is to hear this case in 2016 to clarify where the jurisdiction of law extends to and if Mesa will be granted qualified immunity with no clear contradiction to the constitution.Dean, Jamie. "Be Reasonable: Qualified Immunity, After-Discovered Facts, and the Case of Hernandez v. Mesa." Be Reasonable: Qualified Immunity, After-Discovered Facts, and the Case of Hernandez v. Mesa. Womble Carlyle, Oct.-Nov. 2016. Web. 10 Nov. 2016. Politicizing the criminal as the enemy subjects them not to law but unlimited sovereignty, enabling the state to justify sacrifice of the political community and making civil war inevitableLajous, 12 – doctor of Law at Yale, professor and researcher at Centro de Investigación y Docencia Económica, a Mexican center of research and higher education specialized in social sciences (Alejandro Madrazo, "Criminals and enemies? The Mexican drug trafficker in official discourse and in narcocorridos," translated by Fernanda Alonso)bghs-BI When the legitimacy and existence of a population is in question, politics become murderous – the entirety of the world is reduced to bare life in an attempt to rid the public sphere of all risk. The only option becomes the extermination of all lifeDuarte, 5 – professor of Philosophy at Universidade Federal do Paraná (André, "Biopolitics and the dissemination of violence: the Arendtian critique of the present," April 2005, http://works.bepress.com/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1017andcontext=andre_duarte)//bghs-BI Part three: El PapelThe judge should adopt mestiza consciousness in order to challenge the Borderlands.Dualistic thinking is the root cause of all oppression. Adopt the mestizo consciousness and break down dualistic modes of thinking. The Borderlands are a thought experiment that forces us the imagine people, identities and cultures as they exist in various overlapping borderlands. Engaging and transcending rigid barriers leads to a psychic break that could lead to global change.The judge has a voice in the debate community and speaks through their ballot on the topic. By adopting the mestiza consciousness, the judge shifts from an objective to a subjective position. The objective position forces the judges to divorce themselves from their subjective feelings, which guide their actions, i.e. intuitions. Subjectivity reintroduces the others voice into debate. Koh and Niemi '15(Ben Koh, Rebar Niemi, How Do I Reach These Kids?: An Affirmation of Polyvocal Debate, http://nsdupdate.com/2015/09/15/how-do-i-reach-these-kids-an-affirmation-of-polyvocal-debate-by-ben-koh-rebar-niemi/, September 15, 2015) The pedagogical practices should also be used to give Latinx students the ability to express themselves. To silence the Affirmative by T/Theory is the silence of Latinx culture. T/Theory also forces me to look down on Latinx culture as un-educational and unfair in the debate community. Salazar-Jerez and Fránquiz"Ni de aquí, ni de allá: Latin@1 Youth Crossing Linguistic And Cultural Borders" María E. Fránquiz University of Texas at San Antonio María del Carmen Salazar-Jerez University of Denver Journal of Border Educational Research Volume 6 l Number 2 l 2007 DD Page 105-106. 2ACantiblacknesscapcourt clog | 11/19/16 |
GHILL Natives AffTournament: Greenhill | Round: 1 | Opponent: Klein Oak AG | Judge: Natives aff1ACPart 1: Case====The resolution demands that we discuss nuclear power through the lens of the liberal Humanist discourse of the settler colonial state that will always undermine the interests and the demands of the natives for land. We constantly see the use of rhetoric in discussions of nuclear power framed around protecting the settler and to keep them from feeling guilty. This discussion would merely manifest re-center the colonizer and the colonized systems of exploitation that reproduces because of the grand structure of settler colonialism. ==== Meet Charley Colorado, a man part of the Navajo who lived in his ancestral sheepherding grounds where the United States had uranium mine shafts in 1957. Today he faces extreme consequences as a result of the US's failure to notify indigenous people with the dangers and consequences of radioactive waste that they were being exposed to.Brandon Loomis, the Republic, azcentral.com ====The pacific islands and southwestern regions of the United States are plagued by nuclear colonialism- the resolution's focus on countries relationship to nuclear power paves over those whose land an lives have been irreparably changed by nuclear energy. We much attune our discourse to those areas that are constantly asked to be forgotten==== Nuclear testing, uranium mining, and waste dumping has all occured at the expense of Indigenous lives and their land. While the countries gain access to the benefits of entering the nuclear community, all the advantages to nuclear energy that the negative discusses come at the bodily and cultural destruction of native bodies, there is blood on their hands.Endres 09 (Endres, Danielle. "The Rhetoric of Nuclear Colonialism: Rhetorical Exclusion of American Indian Arguments in the Yucca Mountain Nuclear Waste Siting Decision." Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies 6.1 (2009): 39-60. JSTOR. Web. 19 Aug. 2016.) ====Thus, we demand that the production of nuclear power ought to be prohibited. The 1AC is a form of indigenous activism and resistance that is key to breakdown the discursive structures that maintain global settler colonialism. Nuclear colonialism is not only witnessed in the acts of nuclear waste and dumping but also the rhetoric in which we discuss nuclear power will always exclude the native. ==== Settler colonialism is the impetus and structure that produces indigenous, racial violence, and neoliberalism. White settler alienation from land and maintenance of excess on land that sets the impetus for neoliberal domination- any alternative that endorses unclear power or the state will always reproduce indigenous violenceTuck and Yang 12 Reliance on state based solutions for native persons only involves the reification of settler colonial oppressionBarker 12 Part 2 is the ROBThe ROB is to vote for the debater that best deconstructs settler colonialism. I advocate the judge to adopt an alternative framework through red pedagogy. Decolonization is a movement that is a constant process to challenge entrenched thoughts and modes of thinking.Grande 4 Only decolonization can solve other forms of oppression within settler culture.Churchill, 3 (Ward Churchill, I am Indigenist: Notes on the Ideology of the Fourth World, Acts of Rebellion: The Ward Churchill Reader, p. _) Only having a willingness to exterminate the settler can ensure the destruction of U.S. colonialism.Meister, 11 (Robert Meister, prof of Social and Political Thought @ UC Santa Cruz, After Evil: A Politics of Human Rights, p. google books, note: ev is gender-modified) Evaluating abstract philosophies before issues of oppression is nonsensical – it's just a way to avoid confronting oppressionMatsuda '89 ~Mari, Associate Professor of Law @ the University of Hawaii, "When the First Quail Calls: Multiple Consciousness as Jurisprudential Method", 11 Women's Rts. L. Rep. 7 1989~ | 9/17/16 |
Natives AffTournament: Grapevine | Round: 2 | Opponent: St Johns AW | Judge: Marilyn Myrick Natives affPart 1: Case====The resolution demands that we discuss nuclear power through the lens of the liberal Humanist discourse of the settler colonial state that will always undermine the interests and the demands of the natives for land. We constantly see the use of rhetoric in discussions of nuclear power framed around protecting the settler and to keep them from feeling guilty. This discussion would merely manifest re-center the colonizer and the colonized systems of exploitation that reproduces because of the grand structure of settler colonialism. ==== Meet Charley Colorado, a man part of the Navajo who lived in his ancestral sheepherding grounds where the United States had uranium mine shafts in 1957. Today he faces extreme consequences as a result of the US's failure to notify indigenous people with the dangers and consequences of radioactive waste that they were being exposed to.Brandon Loomis, the Republic, azcentral.com ====The pacific islands and southwestern regions of the United States are plagued by nuclear colonialism- the resolution's focus on countries relationship to nuclear power paves over those whose land an lives have been irreparably changed by nuclear energy. We much attune our discourse to those areas that are constantly asked to be forgotten==== Nuclear testing, uranium mining, and waste dumping has all occured at the expense of Indigenous lives and their land. While the countries gain access to the benefits of entering the nuclear community, all the advantages to nuclear energy that the negative discusses come at the bodily and cultural destruction of native bodies, there is blood on their hands.Endres 09 (Endres, Danielle. "The Rhetoric of Nuclear Colonialism: Rhetorical Exclusion of American Indian Arguments in the Yucca Mountain Nuclear Waste Siting Decision." Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies 6.1 (2009): 39-60. JSTOR. Web. 19 Aug. 2016.) ====Thus, we demand that the production of nuclear power ought to be prohibited. The 1AC is a form of indigenous activism and resistance that is key to breakdown the discursive structures that maintain global settler colonialism. Nuclear colonialism is not only witnessed in the acts of nuclear waste and dumping but also the rhetoric in which we discuss nuclear power will always exclude the native. ==== Settler colonialism is the impetus and structure that produces indigenous, racial violence, and neoliberalism. White settler alienation from land and maintenance of excess on land that sets the impetus for neoliberal domination- any alternative that endorses unclear power or the state will always reproduce indigenous violenceTuck and Yang 12 Part 2 is TheoryProcedural arguments like T and theory are just another tool to maintain settler colonialism and whiteness in debate and this is a reverse voting issue – their reading of procedurals replicates the disciplinary power of the state over native populations. Think about it, the negative will constantly change the goal posts of what is considered "acceptable" to benefit their privileged stance in debate, this is no different than the history of broken treaties and trading in glass beads that have been staples of whiteness. Their interpretation of debate is an attempt to erase Indigeneity to create another space of exception which is key to maintain the sovereignty of settlerismBarker 12 Part 3 is the ROBThe ROB is to vote for the debater that best deconstructs settler colonialism. I advocate the judge to adopt an alternative framework through red pedagogy. Decolonization is a movement that is a constant process to challenge entrenched thoughts and modes of thinking.Grande 4 Evaluating abstract philosophies before issues of oppression is nonsensical – it's just a way to avoid confronting oppressionMatsuda '89 ~Mari, Associate Professor of Law @ the University of Hawaii, "When the First Quail Calls: Multiple Consciousness as Jurisprudential Method", 11 Women's Rts. L. Rep. 7 1989~ | 9/11/16 |
ST MARKS poems affTournament: St Marks | Round: 3 | Opponent: idk | Judge: Jonathan Horowitz Poems Affl poblamiento de América, Our existence in this place isn't neutral. Welcome to Dallas- a land muddled with a genocidal history- the Kiowa, Comanche, Sioux, Crows, Blackfeet and other tribes were systematically exterminated in order for structures like St. Marks. Our fugitive epistemology of poetry reads this city spatially and temporally as a place informed by colonialism; this is how we unsettle the settlerMartineau and Ritskes 14 (Jarrett Martineau , University of Victoria, and Eric Ritskes, University of Toronto, "Fugitive indigeneity: Reclaiming the terrain of decolonial struggle through Indigenous art", 2014, Decolonization: Indigeneity, Education and Society Vol. 3, No. 1 pg 5-9)/ warner There are forms of colonialism in which we are not usually aware of, such as the Nuclear! Nuclear production, at every stage, happens at the risk of the lives and culture of indigenous populations. Whether it be through of exploitation of natural resources, testing or dumping, these forms of nuclear colonialism and environmental racism are well and alive today. Thus, prohibiting the production of nuclear power would eliminate the continued destruction of native populations through nuclear production.Endres 09 (Endres, Danielle. "The Rhetoric of Nuclear Colonialism: Rhetorical Exclusion of American Indian Arguments in the Yucca Mountain Nuclear Waste Siting Decision." Communication and Critical/Cultural Studies 6.1 (2009): 39-60. JSTOR. Web. 19 Aug. 2016.) Settler colonialism is the impetus and structure that produces indigenous, racial violence, and neoliberalism. White settler alienation from land and maintenance of excess on land that sets the impetus for neoliberal domination- any alternative that endorses unclear power or the state will always reproduce indigenous violenceTuck and Yang 12 ====The 1AC is a form of indigenous activism and resistance that is key to breakdown the discursive structures that maintain global settler colonialism. Nuclear colonialism is not only witnessed in the acts of nuclear waste and dumping but also the rhetoric in which we discuss nuclear power will always exclude the native. ==== The ROB is to vote for the debater that best deconstructs settler colonialism. I advocate the judge to adopt an alternative framework through red pedagogy. Decolonization is a movement that is a constant process to challenge entrenched thoughts and modes of thinking.Grande 4 Only having a willingness to exterminate the settler can ensure the destruction of U.S. colonialism.Meister, 11 (Robert Meister, prof of Social and Political Thought @ UC Santa Cruz, After Evil: A Politics of Human Rights, p. google books, note: ev is gender-modified) We have been called the IndiansWe have been called Native AmericansWe have been called Hostilehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4xwN3yPZA0. A Tribe Called Red - We Are The Halluci Nation Ft. John Trudell and Northern Voice (Official video) And we should be. | 10/16/16 |
Open Source
| Filename | Date | Uploaded By | Delete |
|---|