Northland Christian England Neg

Version 4.1 by Kaitlyn England on 2016/09/10 15:14

Tournament	Round	Opponent	Judge	Cites	Round Report	Open Source	Edit/Delete
Grapevine	2	Southlake Carroll SM	Abbie Chapman

Tournament

Round

Opponent

Judge

Cites

Round Report

Open Source

Edit/Delete

Grapevine

Southlake Carroll SM

Abbie Chapman

tick

pencil delete

Tournament

Round

Report

To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.

Cites

Entry	Date
libertarianism neg Tournament: Grapevine \| Round: 2 \| Opponent: Southlake Carroll SM \| Judge: Abbie Chapman I value morality because ought is defined as a moral obligation. The limits of human knowledge necessitate rejecting government coercion. Powell 13, Aaron Ross Powell. “The Humble Case for Liberty.” Libertarianism.org. October 17th, 2013. http://www.libertarianism.org/publications/essays/humble-case-liberty The virtue of humility… use their nightsticks. Thus the standard is maintaining limited government, prefer the standard 1) States only exist because of the social contract, an agreement between the citizens and the state so the state protects the citizens' rights in exchange for the citizens giving up some of their rights. If the state infringes on the rights it was made to protect then it becomes self-defeating and by definition can no longer be considered just as the resolution requires. 2) When people are oppressed that means that they do not have the capacity to make their own choices. Since morality is based off of what choices people make it can no longer be looked to if people are coerced into acting in ways other than if they had the freedom to choose. This means that if people are oppressed morality is unattainable because they can no longer act with morality in mind. I contend that prohibiting the production of nuclear power restricts the rights of citizens and creates a tyrannical government. Libertarianism requires a minimalist state and would thus not regulate nuclear power. Vallentyne, Vallentyne, Peter. “Libertarianism.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. January 07, 2014. Web. August 16, 2016. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/libertarianism/. MP Libertarianism requires that …one's fair share. 6 Agents have a right to access natural resources. A government must respect this right. Vallentyne Vallentyne, Peter. “Libertarianism.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. January 07, 2014. Web. August 16, 2016. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/libertarianism/. MP A plausible account o… use and appropriation.	9/10/16

Entry

Date

libertarianism neg

Tournament: Grapevine | Round: 2 | Opponent: Southlake Carroll SM | Judge: Abbie Chapman
I value morality because ought is defined as a moral obligation. The limits of human knowledge necessitate rejecting government coercion. Powell 13,
Aaron Ross Powell. “The Humble Case for Liberty.” Libertarianism.org. October 17th, 2013. http://www.libertarianism.org/publications/essays/humble-case-liberty
The virtue of humility… use their nightsticks.

Thus the standard is maintaining limited government, prefer the standard

1) States only exist because of the social contract, an agreement between the citizens and the state so the state protects the citizens' rights in exchange for the citizens giving up some of their rights. If the state infringes on the rights it was made to protect then it becomes self-defeating and by definition can no longer be considered just as the resolution requires.

2) When people are oppressed that means that they do not have the capacity to make their own choices. Since morality is based off of what choices people make it can no longer be looked to if people are coerced into acting in ways other than if they had the freedom to choose. This means that if people are oppressed morality is unattainable because they can no longer act with morality in mind.

I contend that prohibiting the production of nuclear power restricts the rights of citizens and creates a tyrannical government.

Libertarianism requires a minimalist state and would thus not regulate nuclear power. Vallentyne,
Vallentyne, Peter. “Libertarianism.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. January 07, 2014. Web. August 16, 2016. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/libertarianism/. MP
Libertarianism requires that …one's fair share. 6

Agents have a right to access natural resources. A government must respect this right. Vallentyne
Vallentyne, Peter. “Libertarianism.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. January 07, 2014. Web. August 16, 2016. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/libertarianism/. MP
A plausible account o… use and appropriation.

9/10/16

Open Source

Filename

Date

Uploaded By

Delete

Add/Modify Entry

Modify a Round Add a New Round

Select a currently entered round to modify:

Tournament:
Round:

Opponent:
Judge:

Please fill out a round report below. Include information about the 1AC, 1NC, block strategy, 2NR, notable aff tricks, etc.

Round Report:

Enter cites from this debate below, with a title describing the argument. You can create more than one "entry" per round, to help keep things organized. You should NOT paste full text cards here, only cites - if you want to disclose open source, upload a document on the next page as well.

IMPORTANT NOTE: The Cites box will only accept unformatted text. Wiki syntax (e.g. from Verbatim), is strongly preferred.

Entry Title:

IMPORTANT NOTE: Your file will automatically be re-named on upload based on the provided info.

You can only upload one combined open source speech doc per round - uploading a new file will overwrite the old one.

Computed file name:

You're about to submit the following information:

After clicking "Add Entry", be patient! The page will automatically reload when your info has uploaded. If you navigate away from the page before it reloads, info may be lost.

Note: By submitting to the wiki, you grant the right for the information to be freely displayed, reproduced and archived.

Tags:

Created by Margaret Purcell on 2016/09/09 18:12

History

Northland Christian England Neg

Cites

libertarianism neg

Open Source

Add/Modify Entry

Quick Links

Schools