Tournament: Any | Round: 1 | Opponent: Any | Judge: Any
T about what the “correct” way to interpret English from a grammatical or linguistic standpoint constructs an impartial and “rational” reading of the resolution which excludes marginalized voices and presumes that the dominant way of speaking is truth.
Rebar Niemi, 9/22/15, Mr. Nebel’s neighborhood, OR Nebel Tea – I sip it. http://premierdebatetoday.com/2015/09/22/nebel-t-i-sip-it/
No more neighborhood...correct resolutional meaning.

Even if T is not based on semantics, forcing debaters to always debate the topic still constrains advocacy by relegating what issues are “important”
In Defense of Inclusion by John Scoggin and Bob Overing September 10, 2015
Nebel also argues...of truth-testing.

Using T to limit jurisdiction:

1. abstracts away from reality of oppression
   2. devalues and otherizes non-traditional debate styles
   3. discourages diversity by enforcing a narrow interpretation of what debate should look like
   In Defense of Inclusion by John Scoggin and Bob Overing September 10, 2015
   If we can...to take seriously.

The process of Topic selection reinforces the perspective of the dominant ideology. For example, the active voice of the topic outsources agency to governmental bodies that has been historical denied to minorities.
12-2014 Against the grain : the challenges of black discourse within intercollegiate policy debate. Tiffany Yvonne Dillard-Knox University of Louisville
On face, this...exclusion from Debate.

Thus the advocacy:
Public colleges and universities ought to prohibit topicality as a restriction on minorities engaging in performance debate in college policy debate.

Go Homers, Makeovers or Takeovers?  A Privilege Analysis of Debate as a Gaming Simulation
Ede Warner, Jr, PhD in Communications, 2003, “Go Homers, Makeovers or Takeovers? A Privilege Analysis of Debate as a Gaming Simulation,” Contemporary Argumentation and Debate
A more effective...equal playing field.

Instead of being faced with the choice of forced assimilation, Non-traditional debate styles allow black debaters to combine their cultural identity with the format and perspective of debate.

12-2014 Against the grain : the challenges of black discourse within intercollegiate policy debate. Tiffany Yvonne Dillard-Knox University of Louisville
Shelton K. Hill...while doing so.

Participation in policy discussions re-entrenches inequalities by accepting and legitimizing structural constraints. Critiquing policy from the outside is a better activist strategy.
Young — Iris Marion Young, Professor of Political Science at the University of Chicago, holds a Ph.D. in Philosophy from the Pennsylvania State University, 2001 (“Activist Challenges to Deliberative Democracy,” Political Theory, Volume 29, Number 5, October, Available Online to Subscribing Institutions via JSTOR, p. 682-685)
Let us suppose...give some examples. 

Criticism and real world advocacy is key to reclaiming agency from the state to us as debaters.
Polson 12 (Dana Roe Polson, PhD in Language Literacy and Culture, UMBC, Baltimore city public and public charter schools high school teacher, “’Longing for Theory:’ Performance Debate in Action” Dissertain directed by Dr. Christine Mallinson, Assistant Professor,  Language, Literacy, and Culture pp. 256-257)CEFS
One of the...to do something.

The ROTB is to challenge norms and procedures of traditional debate to challenge oppression in the debate community.
To weigh links, we see which model of debate and topicality best controls the internal link to inclusion.
Dillard-Knox, Tiffany Yvonne, "Against the grain : the challenges of black discourse within intercollegiate policy debate." (2014). Electronic Theses and Dissertations. Paper 2161. http://dx.doi.org/10.18297/etd/2161

Underview
Cross-x checks for theory/T:
If debaters are given the opportunity to resolve fairness questions, then there is less frivolous theory. Frivolous theory is bad because it’s often more abusive than the abuse it claims to solve, and so recycled it’s not educational

Tournament: Any | Round: 1 | Opponent: Any | Judge: Any
Nuclear accidents like Fukushima are psychologically destructive to women- they face social exclusion and depression from nuclear anxiety which lasts long after the accident itself.
Martin 15:
Becky Martin 2015 (Becky Martin is a researcher at Southampton University specializing in radiation protection) “Nuclear fallout: the mental health consequences of radiation” The Guardian
https://www.theguardian.com/science/brain-flapping/2015/aug/09/nagasaki-anniversary-radiation-nuclear-mental-health
Ionising radiation and… for their society.

This outweighs- lack of education causes Japanese society to blame the individual mental illness- leads to discrimination and social exclusion.
Veting 15:
Iris Vegting 2015“Stigma on Mental Illness in Japan: Causes, Consequences, and suggestions for Improvement” Understanding International Mental Health
https://understandinginternationalmentalhealth.wordpress.com/2015/05/28/stigma-on-mental-illness-in-japan-causes-consequences-and-suggestions-for-improvement/
Japanese society has… on mental health.

Nuclear denial after Fukushima is a result of hypermasculinity- this constructs women as “irrational” and prohibits participation in the public sphere
Kimura and Katano 13:
Aya H. Kimura and Yohei Katano 2013 “Farming after the Fukushima accident: a feminist political ecology analysis of organic agriculture”
http://socialsciences.people.hawaii.edu/publications_lib/ahk202013.pdf
In addition, the… the official pronouncement.

The misinformation spread by the government and media after these disasters was a strategy to protect corporate and government interests. The government uses “Radiophobia” as a rhetorical tool to paint victims of nuclear power accidents as “irrational” or “hysterical” to diminish the impact of accidents and to shield those responsible from criticism. O'Flaherty 15:
Erin O'Flaherty 2015 (Activist)  “Radiophobia: The social consequences of Fukushima” SOTT: Signs of The Times
https://www.sott.net/article/308199-Radiophobia-The-social-consequences-of-Fukushima
There is absolutely… in mainstream Japanese 

Nuclear denial and misinformation play on ableist fears, increasing number of abortions. When women speak up, they are silenced, exacerbating harms to mental health.
Barker 16:
Daniel Barker 2016 “Parent's worst nightmare: Wave of babies born in Japan with extra arms and legs due to Fukushima radiation... Stillbirth numbers on the rise” Natural News
Despite the scientific… the entire world.

Text:The national government of Japan should ban nuclear power and decommission existing nuclear power plants.
The national government of Japan should ban the production of nuclear power.
CCNE 13 Citizens’ Commission on Nuclear Energy, Organization Aiming at Fundamental Reform of Nuclear Energy Policy, “Our path to a nuclear-free Japan: an interim report Executive Summary,” October 2013 

Given the Fukushima… with energy policies.
Solvency
Japan’s nuclear restart is on the rise -Conservatives estimate 12 reactors will start by 2018
Thompson 16
Nancy Slater-Thompson 2016 “Five and a half years after Fukushima, 3 of Japan’s 54 nuclear reactors are operating” US Energy Information Administration
http://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=27912

Since the accident… nuclear capacity restoration.
Anti-nuclear movement is the first step to deconstructing the hyper-masculine state in order to reconfigure women citizenship
Germer and Mackier 14:
Andrea Germer, Vera Mackie, Ulrike Wöhr 2014 “Gender, Nation and State in Modern Japan”

Women in the… of hegemonic masculinity 

Framework
The standard is to maximize moral inclusion by challenging dominant regimes of knowledge that structure our political reality.

Analytic

Understanding the particularities of individuals’ perspectives requires acknowledging how political powers like the state have the capacity to create structures of truth under which people frame their understanding of right and wrong.
Rider:
Shawn Rider 1999 “Michel Foucault: Truth and Power” http://www.wdog.com/rider/writings/foucault.htm 

The structure is… of the society.

Ensuring that voices are included the political system requires questioning the assumptions behind the stratification of individuals. Winters and Leighton 99:
Winter, D. D., and Leighton, D. C. (2001). Structural violence. In D. J. Christie, R. V. Wagner, and D. D. Winter (Eds.), Peace, conflict, and violence: Peace psychology in the 21st century. New York: Prentice-Hall. CM
Finally, to recognize… appreciation of diversity

Participation in politics is key to challenging oppression of marginalized groups- cannot represent their interests without their voices.
Young 2:
Young, Iris Marion. Justice and the Politics of Difference. Princeton, NJ: Princeton UP, 1990. Print. CM
Second, because it… facilitates such expression.