Memorial Qin Neg
| Tournament | Round | Opponent | Judge | Cites | Round Report | Open Source | Edit/Delete |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Longhorn Classic UT | 2 | William Coltzer | Tyrell Vanwinkle |
|
| ||
| Seven Lakes | 1 | Salma Calvo |
|
| |||
| Texas City | 2 |
|
| ||||
| UH | 2 |
|
|
| Tournament | Round | Report |
|---|
To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.
Cites
| Entry | Date |
|---|---|
JANFEB-CP-Terrible Hate Speech CPTournament: UH | Round: 2 | Opponent: | Judge: The standard of this round will be utilitarianism which states that the greatest good for the greatest amount of people is the best way to achieve morality. Utilitarianism prioritizes the pleasure of as many people as possible. I will provide 2 justifications: Justification 1: Util protects life first which is a prerequisite to any other value or standard. The Utilitarian Response. pg. 141-2. Robert Goodin is a fellow in philosophy at the Australian National Defense University. Now, I will present my counter plan. Part 1 is the Text: Part 2 is the competition: Part 3 is Net Benefits: C1: Hate speech causes hate crime. C2: Hate speech causes minorities to commit suicide. The more negative a nickname or slur used to refer to an immigrant group, the C3: Hate speech is a precursor to genocide. While hate speech can often be dismissed as bigoted ranting or merely painful words, it A hate speech ban is key to deter perpetrators of hatred from giving hate speech, thus avoiding all these impacts mentioned above. A hate speech ban would show bigots that their views are unwelcome. Jensen 93. Ejner J. Jensen, Senate Assembly Chair, 2-8-1993, "The pros and cons of a policy covering hate speech," The University Record, http:ur.umich.edu/9293/Feb08'93/8.htm AD Universities have a right and duty to provide an educational environment, a climate of civility I-Law DA: Link: ILaw banned hate speech. The international community has chosen to outlaw racist hate propaganda. Article 4 of the International Convention US adherence to international law concerning hate speech is key to credibility in international human rights. Recent scandals involving right-wing hatemongers like Phil Robertson, Donald Sterling, Bill Maher, and the Sigma Impact: ILaw solves multiple scenarios for extinction—US compliance with ILaw shapes global ILaw compliance Turns case—the Constitution says we have to follow ILaw Please vote Neg. | 2/9/17 |
JANFEB-NC-Lay UtilTournament: Texas City | Round: 2 | Opponent: | Judge: My value is morality which tells us what is right and wrong to do. Morality is the ultimate motivation for any action. The standard of this round will be utilitarianism which states that the greatest good for the greatest amount of people is the best way to achieve morality. Utilitarianism prioritizes the pleasure of as many people as possible. I will provide 2 justifications: Justification 1: Util protects life first which is a prerequisite to any other value or standard. The Utilitarian Response. pg. 141-2. Robert Goodin is a fellow in philosophy at the Australian National Defense University. C1: Hate speech causes hate crime. C2: Hate speech causes minorities to commit suicide. The more negative a nickname or slur used to refer to an immigrant group, the C3: Hate speech is a precursor to genocide. While hate speech can often be dismissed as bigoted ranting or merely painful words, it A hate speech ban is key to deter perpetrators of hatred from giving hate speech, thus avoiding all these impacts mentioned above. A hate speech ban would show bigots that their views are unwelcome. Jensen 93. Ejner J. Jensen, Senate Assembly Chair, 2-8-1993, "The pros and cons of a policy covering hate speech," The University Record, http:ur.umich.edu/9293/Feb08'93/8.htm AD Universities have a right and duty to provide an educational environment, a climate of civility C4: International law As a world superpower and global leader, US policies are likely analyzed closely. Adelman 13: Link: ILaw banned hate speech. The international community has chosen to outlaw racist hate propaganda. Article 4 of the International Convention US adherence to international law concerning hate speech is key to credibility in international human rights. Recent scandals involving right-wing hatemongers like Phil Robertson, Donald Sterling, Bill Maher, and the Sigma Impact: ILaw solves multiple scenarios for extinction—US compliance with ILaw shapes global ILaw compliance Turns case—the Constitution says we have to follow ILaw Don’t buy any unwarranted arguments- my opponent is just trying to avoid having to debate this important impact without going to the trouble of bringing up evidence. Also, don’t buy an argument that states this is far-fetched; it is clearly not. Things such as accidental nuclear war could happen at any time and trigger global extinction, US compliance with I-law helps gives it the credibility to tell other countries to follow certain international laws that help prevent these extinction scenarios. Please vote Neg. | 2/9/17 |
Open Source
| Filename | Date | Uploaded By | Delete |
|---|---|---|---|
12/3/16 | andrewqin02@gmailcom |
|