Holy Cross Ziegler Aff

Last modified by Administrator on 2017/08/29 03:36

Tournament	Round	Opponent	Judge	Cites	Round Report	Open Source	Edit/Delete
Glenbrooks	1	Lake Highland Prep AA	Akhil Gandra

Tournament

Round

Opponent

Judge

Cites

Round Report

Open Source

Edit/Delete

Glenbrooks

Lake Highland Prep AA

Akhil Gandra

tick

pencil delete

Tournament

Round

Report

To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.

Cites

Entry	Date
Reasonability AFF Tournament: Glenbrooks \| Round: 1 \| Opponent: Lake Highland Prep AA \| Judge: Akhil Gandra I value retributive justice. Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy '14 ( "Retributive Justice" Published Jun. 18th 2014. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/justice-retributive/) The concept of retributive justice...contested and problematic. In order to uphold retributive justice, the criterion is upholding accountability. Inherency Supreme Court has created a reasonability standard to determine whether or not qualified immunity is justified. Schott ’16: Richard G. Schott, J.D., September 2012. "Qualified Immunity: How It Protects Law Enforcement Officers," FBI, https://leb.fbi.gov/2012/september/qualified-immunity-how-it-protects-law-enforcement-officers Recognizing this dilemma...would have known.”9 QI in cases of the 4th amendment gives officers two standards of reasonability to be acquitted leading to overprotection and skewed results. Hassel 09, Diana. (Associate Professor, Roger Williams University School of Law) "EXCESSIVE REASONABLENESS." Indiana Law Review 43.117 (2009): 118-42. Web. 24 Oct. 2016. https://mckinneylaw.iu.edu/ilr/pdf/vol43p117.pdf. Premier Operating on two different fronts, the Court...needlessly¶ complicated decisions.¶ People have different experiences, and thus different perspectives. Legacy Project: Every person has...difference to your perspective. Thus the plan: The United States Supreme Court defines reasonability as any action necessary to ensure the safety of citizens when there is an immediate danger. Adv. 1: Police Accountability Qualified immunity currently protects bad cops. Carter ’15: Tom Carter, 11-12-2015, "US Supreme Court expands immunity for killer cops," No Publication, https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2015/11/12/pers-n12.html In March of 2010, Texas Department...asphyxiations, beatings and taserings. Qualified immunity allows for abuse in the justice system. The only solution is to give civilians a fair chance in the court. Wright ’15: Sam Wright, 10-31-2016, "Want to Fight Police Misconduct? Reform Qualified Immunity," Above the Law, http://abovethelaw.com/2015/11/want-to-fight-police-misconduct-reform-qualified-immunity/ In order to truly hold police...push to make it happen. Adv. 2: Better Policing Lawsuits allow for police departments to create better policies. Schwartz ‘10 Schwartz '10 (Joanna C. Schwartz. Acting Professor of Law, UCLA School of Law. "WHAT POLICE LEARN FROM LAWSUITS" 33 CARDOZO L. REV. (2010). http://law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/default/files/event/265497/media/slspublic/What_Police_Learn_From_Lawsuits.pdf ) For these departments,...internal reporting systems Aff would be a crucial step in repairing relationships with police De Stefan 17 De Stefan, Lindsey, (J.D. Candidate, 2017, Seton Hall University School of Law) “No Man Is Above the Law and No Man Is Below It:” How Qualified Immunity Reform Could Create Accountability and Curb Widespread Police Misconduct" (2017). Law School Student Scholarship. Paper 850. Premier By beginning to mending the...trust that is so crucial. Adv. 3: Reduces Violence The vagueness of reasonableness allows for police officers to not know the bright line of excessive force. This allows for police officers to be violent in their dealings with the public. Alpert and Smith ’94: Alpert and Smith, 1994 ( Geoffrey P. Alpert William C. Smith. Professors at University of South Carolina. How Reasonable Is the Reasonable Man: Police and Excessive Force. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Volume 85 Issue 2 Fall. http://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=6818andcontext=jclc) The Commission Report discussed...reports at all. Limiting qualified immunity causes police to learn about the law, which leads to better policing and training. This guarantees safety of the community and reduces violence. Deidrich ‘8: Diedrich '08 (Dawn M. Diedrich, Deputy Director of Legal Services and Special Agent, Georgia Bureau of Investigation, Decatur, Georgia. "Rigid Order of Battle': A Police Training Perspective on the Qualified Immunity Analysis" http://www.policechiefmagazine.org/magazine/index.cfm?fuseaction=display_archandarticle_id=1551andissue_id=72008) In 2001, the Supreme Court...constitutional rights of individuals. Better training has reduces police violence overall. Klinger, '12 (David A. Klinger. Professor at Saint Louis University School of Law. POLICE TRAINING AS AN INSTRUMENT OF ACCOUNTABILITY. http://connection.ebscohost.com/c/articles/86247519/police-training-as-instrument-accountability) The matter of how to hold police...legitimate police objective.	11/20/16

Entry

Date

Reasonability AFF

Tournament: Glenbrooks | Round: 1 | Opponent: Lake Highland Prep AA | Judge: Akhil Gandra
I value retributive justice.
Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy '14
( "Retributive Justice" Published Jun. 18th 2014. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/justice-retributive/)
The concept of retributive justice...contested and problematic.

In order to uphold retributive justice, the criterion is upholding accountability.

Inherency

Supreme Court has created a reasonability standard to determine whether or not qualified immunity is justified. Schott ’16:
Richard G. Schott, J.D., September 2012. "Qualified Immunity: How It Protects Law Enforcement Officers," FBI, https://leb.fbi.gov/2012/september/qualified-immunity-how-it-protects-law-enforcement-officers
Recognizing this dilemma...would have known.”9

QI in cases of the 4th amendment gives officers two standards of reasonability to be acquitted leading to overprotection and skewed results.
Hassel 09, Diana. (Associate Professor, Roger Williams University School of Law) "EXCESSIVE REASONABLENESS." Indiana Law Review 43.117 (2009): 118-42. Web. 24 Oct. 2016. https://mckinneylaw.iu.edu/ilr/pdf/vol43p117.pdf. Premier
Operating on two different fronts, the Court...needlessly¶ complicated decisions.¶

People have different experiences, and thus different perspectives.
Legacy Project:
Every person has...difference to your perspective.

Thus the plan: The United States Supreme Court defines reasonability as any action necessary to ensure the safety of citizens when there is an immediate danger.

Adv. 1: Police Accountability

Qualified immunity currently protects bad cops. Carter ’15:
Tom Carter, 11-12-2015, "US Supreme Court expands immunity for killer cops," No Publication, https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2015/11/12/pers-n12.html
In March of 2010, Texas Department...asphyxiations, beatings and taserings.

Qualified immunity allows for abuse in the justice system. The only solution is to give civilians a fair chance in the court. Wright ’15:
Sam Wright, 10-31-2016, "Want to Fight Police Misconduct? Reform Qualified Immunity," Above the Law, http://abovethelaw.com/2015/11/want-to-fight-police-misconduct-reform-qualified-immunity/
In order to truly hold police...push to make it happen.

Adv. 2: Better Policing

Lawsuits allow for police departments to create better policies. Schwartz ‘10
Schwartz '10 (Joanna C. Schwartz. Acting Professor of Law, UCLA School of Law. "WHAT POLICE LEARN FROM LAWSUITS" 33 CARDOZO L. REV. (2010). http://law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/default/files/event/265497/media/slspublic/What_Police_Learn_From_Lawsuits.pdf )
For these departments,...internal reporting systems

Aff would be a crucial step in repairing relationships with police
De Stefan 17
De Stefan, Lindsey, (J.D. Candidate, 2017, Seton Hall University School of Law) “No Man Is Above the Law and No Man Is Below It:” How Qualified Immunity Reform Could Create Accountability and Curb Widespread Police Misconduct" (2017). Law School Student Scholarship. Paper 850. Premier
By beginning to mending the...trust that is so crucial.

Adv. 3: Reduces Violence

The vagueness of reasonableness allows for police officers to not know the bright line of excessive force. This allows for police officers to be violent in their dealings with the public. Alpert and Smith ’94:
Alpert and Smith, 1994 ( Geoffrey P. Alpert William C. Smith. Professors at University of South Carolina. How Reasonable Is the Reasonable Man: Police and Excessive Force. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Volume 85 Issue 2 Fall. http://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=6818andcontext=jclc)
The Commission Report discussed...reports at all.

Limiting qualified immunity causes police to learn about the law, which leads to better policing and training. This guarantees safety of the community and reduces violence. Deidrich ‘8:
Diedrich '08 (Dawn M. Diedrich, Deputy Director of Legal Services and Special Agent, Georgia Bureau of Investigation, Decatur, Georgia. "Rigid Order of Battle': A Police Training Perspective on the Qualified Immunity Analysis" http://www.policechiefmagazine.org/magazine/index.cfm?fuseaction=display_archandarticle_id=1551andissue_id=72008)
In 2001, the Supreme Court...constitutional rights of individuals.

Better training has reduces police violence overall. Klinger, '12
(David A. Klinger. Professor at Saint Louis University School of Law. POLICE TRAINING AS AN INSTRUMENT OF ACCOUNTABILITY. http://connection.ebscohost.com/c/articles/86247519/police-training-as-instrument-accountability)
The matter of how to hold police...legitimate police objective.

11/20/16

Open Source

Filename

Date

Uploaded By

Delete

Add/Modify Entry

Modify a Round Add a New Round

Select a currently entered round to modify:

Tournament:
Round:

Opponent:
Judge:

Please fill out a round report below. Include information about the 1AC, 1NC, block strategy, 2NR, notable aff tricks, etc.

Round Report:

Enter cites from this debate below, with a title describing the argument. You can create more than one "entry" per round, to help keep things organized. You should NOT paste full text cards here, only cites - if you want to disclose open source, upload a document on the next page as well.

IMPORTANT NOTE: The Cites box will only accept unformatted text. Wiki syntax (e.g. from Verbatim), is strongly preferred.

Entry Title:

IMPORTANT NOTE: Your file will automatically be re-named on upload based on the provided info.

You can only upload one combined open source speech doc per round - uploading a new file will overwrite the old one.

Computed file name:

You're about to submit the following information:

After clicking "Add Entry", be patient! The page will automatically reload when your info has uploaded. If you navigate away from the page before it reloads, info may be lost.

Note: By submitting to the wiki, you grant the right for the information to be freely displayed, reproduced and archived.

Tags:

Created by Toran Langford on 2016/11/20 04:16

History

Holy Cross Ziegler Aff

Cites

Reasonability AFF

Open Source

Add/Modify Entry

Quick Links

Schools