Harvard Westlake Le Neg

Version 7.1 by Angela Lee on 2017/03/17 18:42

Tournament	Round	Opponent	Judge	Cites	Round Report	Open Source	Edit/Delete
NA	1	NA	NA
NA	2	NA	NA

Tournament

Round

Opponent

Judge

Cites

Round Report

Open Source

Edit/Delete

tick

report

pencil delete

emoticon_unhappy

report

pencil delete

Tournament	Round	Report
NA	1	Opponent: NA \| Judge: NA Public Universities and colleges should establish restrictions on hate speech consistent with Byrnes proposal This includes restrictions on otherwise protected free speech They will remove all other restrictions on protected free speech Byrne 91 Byrne J Peter Associate Professor Georgetown University Law Center "Racial Insults and Free Speech Within the University" Geo LJ 79 (1990) 399 This article examinesand informed judgment 3 The counterplan establishes checks on reverse enforcement chilling effect and slippery slope Byrne 91 Byrne J Peter Associate Professor Georgetown University Law Center "Racial Insults and Free Speech Within the University" Geo LJ 79 (1990) 399 Disciplinary rules areand hurtful ranting Hate speech degrades minorities locking in the squo and ensuring their failure Delgado 2k Richard Delgado - Charles Inglis Thomson Professor of Law University of Colorado JD U California-Berkeley 1974 TOWARD A LEGAL REALIST VIEW OF THE FIRST AMENDMENT Harvard Law Review January 2000 JJN B Hate Speech asacross large groups And hate speech primes society for genocide multiple empirical examples prove Tsesis 09 Tsesis Alexander Loyola University Chicago School of Law "Dignity and speech The regulation of hate speech in a democracy" (2009) Permitting persons orprinciples of democracy AFF Advantage Add-Ons CRT Framing Add-On Standpoint epistemology is the best starting point for moral decisions other methods exclude some viewpoints which makes true analysis of reality impossible Mills 5 - Dominant narratives shape whats counted as real ethics so the standpoint of the oppressed is more likely correct better starting point Edited for ableist language Charles Mills Ideal Theory as Ideology 2005 NS The crucial commonmale-dominated philosophical literature Therefore we should recognize the way racism taints claims for ideological purity Only centering the debate from the view point of the oppressed is equality possible Bell 92 Derrick Bell Weld Professor of Law Harvard University Law School Visiting Professor New York University Law School 1991-92 school year RACIAL REALISM Connecticut Law Review Winter 1992 httpliberalartsiupuiedumpsgEssaysBell20-20Racial20Realismpdf JJN As a veteranis never overcome Thus the standard is resisting racism And this comes before their framework A) A refusal to recognize the way race effects free speech downplay the importance of racism and should lose them this debate Lopez 03 Lpez Gerardo R University of Utah Salt Lake City "The (racially neutral) politics of education A critical race theory perspective" Educational Administration Quarterly 391 (2003) 68-94 How could Schattschneiderlarger social order B) Their lack of minority voices is a conscious choice - Delgado 84 Delgado Richard "The imperial scholar Reflections on a review of civil rights literature" University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1323 (1984) 561-578 It does notno such tradition23 Impacts I VTL Racism destroys self-worth and dignity of those attacked Post 91 ROBERT C POST - Professor of Law School of Law (Boalt Hall) University of California at Berkeley BA Harvard College 1969 JD Yale University 1977 PhD Harvard University 1980 RACIST SPEECH DEMOCRACY AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT William and Mary Law Review 1991 httpscholarshiplawwmeducgiviewcontentcgiarticle=1924context=wmlr JJN C Harm to Individualsits abusive nature3 9 I Marketplace of Ideas Racism harms the marketplace of ideas turns the AC Post 91 ROBERT C POST - Professor of Law School of Law (Boalt Hall) University of California at Berkeley BA Harvard College 1969 JD Yale University 1977 PhD Harvard University 1980 RACIST SPEECH DEMOCRACY AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT William and Mary Law Review 1991 httpscholarshiplawwmeducgiviewcontentcgiarticle=1924context=wmlr JJN D Harm to thestigmatizing victim groups I Deontology Racism is rejected by deontic ideals Post 91 ROBERT C POST - Professor of Law School of Law (Boalt Hall) University of California at Berkeley BA Harvard College 1969 JD Yale University 1977 PhD Harvard University 1980 RACIST SPEECH DEMOCRACY AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT William and Mary Law Review 1991 httpscholarshiplawwmeducgiviewcontentcgiarticle=1924context=wmlr JJN A The Intrinsic Harmof racial inferiority"25 I Education Racism interferes with and harms education Post 91 ROBERT C POST - Professor of Law School of Law (Boalt Hall) University of California at Berkeley BA Harvard College 1969 JD Yale University 1977 PhD Harvard University 1980 RACIST SPEECH DEMOCRACY AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT William and Mary Law Review 1991 httpscholarshiplawwmeducgiviewcontentcgiarticle=1924context=wmlr JJN E Harm to Educationalseek to instill5
NA	2	Opponent: NA \| Judge: NA Public Universities and colleges should establish restrictions on hate speech consistent with Byrnes proposal This includes restrictions on otherwise protected free speech They will remove all other restrictions on protected free speech Byrne 91 Byrne J Peter Associate Professor Georgetown University Law Center "Racial Insults and Free Speech Within the University" Geo LJ 79 (1990) 399 This article examinesand informed judgment 3 The counterplan establishes checks on reverse enforcement chilling effect and slippery slope Byrne 91 Byrne J Peter Associate Professor Georgetown University Law Center "Racial Insults and Free Speech Within the University" Geo LJ 79 (1990) 399 Disciplinary rules areand hurtful ranting Hate speech degrades minorities locking in the squo and ensuring their failure Delgado 2k Richard Delgado - Charles Inglis Thomson Professor of Law University of Colorado JD U California-Berkeley 1974 TOWARD A LEGAL REALIST VIEW OF THE FIRST AMENDMENT Harvard Law Review January 2000 JJN B Hate Speech asacross large groups And hate speech primes society for genocide multiple empirical examples prove Tsesis 09 Tsesis Alexander Loyola University Chicago School of Law "Dignity and speech The regulation of hate speech in a democracy" (2009) Permitting persons orprinciples of democracy Framing Racism must be the starting point of our evaluation without directly addressing it other moral ideals fail to have meaning because unconscious forms of racism filter into the way people see the world We cannot use idealism Bell 92 Derrick Bell Weld Professor of Law Harvard University Law School Visiting Professor New York University Law School 1991-92 school year RACIAL REALISM Connecticut Law Review Winter 1992 httpliberalartsiupuiedumpsgEssaysBell20-20Racial20Realismpdf JJN As a veteranis never overcome Thus the standard is resisting racism A refusal to recognize the way race effects free speech downplay the importance of racism and should lose them this debate Lopez 03 Lpez Gerardo R University of Utah Salt Lake City "The (racially neutral) politics of education A critical race theory perspective" Educational Administration Quarterly 391 (2003) 68-94 How could Schattschneiderlarger social order Harassment DA Title IX investigations are increasing Kingkade 16 Tyler Kingkade There Are Far More Title IX Investigations Of Colleges Than Most People Know Huffington Post June 16 2016 httpwwwhuffingtonpostcomentrytitle-ix-investigations-sexual-harassmentus575f4b0ee4b053d433061b3d AGM The growing backlogofficial told HuffPost The AFF guts effectiveness of Title IX it explodes first amendment opportunism for harassment cases Marcus 08 Kenneth Marcus Higher Education Harassment and First Amendment Opportunism William Mary Bill of Rights Journal Vol 16 Issue 4 2008 NS In one classicFirst Amendment opportunism Title IX is currently effective against harassment this dramatically increases access to higher education Musil 07 Caryn Musil Scaling the Ivory Towers MS Magazine Fall 2007 The Triumphs of Title IX httpwwwfeministorgeducationTriumphsOfTitleIXpdf NS The contrast betweendominated by men Gender equality in higher education and the workforce is key to climate science and innovation Gender Summit 13 Gender Summit 3 North America Diversity Fueling Excellence in Research and Innovation Conference Report 111313 httpswwwnsfgovodoiaactivitiesgendersummitGS3-ConfReportpdf NS Ms Jarrett notedequality he stated Climate innovations are the primary key to solve warming Moniz 15 Ernest Moniz (US Secretary of Energy) Interviewed by David Biello Accelerated Innovation Is the Ultimate Solution to Climate Change Scientific American 121115 httpswwwscientificamericancomarticleaccelerated-innovation-is-the-ultimate-solution-to-climate-change NS PARISFrom "clean coal"a widespread technology Warming leads to extinction multiple scenarios prove Roberts 13 David Roberts - staff writer for Grist If you arent alarmed about climate you arent paying attention Grist January 10 2013 httpgristorgclimate-energyclimate-alarmism-the-idea-is-surreal JJN There was recentlyalarm is adequate

Tournament

Round

Report

Opponent: NA | Judge: NA

Public Universities and colleges should establish restrictions on hate speech consistent with Byrnes proposal This includes restrictions on otherwise protected free speech They will remove all other restrictions on protected free speech Byrne 91

Byrne J Peter Associate Professor Georgetown University Law Center "Racial Insults and Free Speech Within the University" Geo LJ 79 (1990) 399

This article examinesand informed judgment 3

The counterplan establishes checks on reverse enforcement chilling effect and slippery slope Byrne 91

Byrne J Peter Associate Professor Georgetown University Law Center "Racial Insults and Free Speech Within the University" Geo LJ 79 (1990) 399

AFF Advantage Add-Ons
CRT Framing Add-On
Standpoint epistemology is the best starting point for moral decisions other methods exclude some viewpoints which makes true analysis of reality impossible Mills 5

- Dominant narratives shape whats counted as real ethics so the standpoint of the oppressed is more likely correct better starting point
Edited for ableist language
Charles Mills Ideal Theory as Ideology 2005 NS

The crucial commonmale-dominated philosophical literature

Therefore we should recognize the way racism taints claims for ideological purity Only centering the debate from the view point of the oppressed is equality possible Bell 92
Derrick Bell Weld Professor of Law Harvard University Law School Visiting Professor New York University Law School 1991-92 school year RACIAL REALISM Connecticut Law Review Winter 1992 httpliberalartsiupuiedumpsgEssaysBell20-20Racial20Realismpdf JJN
As a veteranis never overcome

Thus the standard is resisting racism

And this comes before their framework

A) A refusal to recognize the way race effects free speech downplay the importance of racism and should lose them this debate Lopez 03

Lpez Gerardo R University of Utah Salt Lake City "The (racially neutral) politics of education A critical race theory perspective" Educational Administration Quarterly 391 (2003) 68-94

How could Schattschneiderlarger social order

B) Their lack of minority voices is a conscious choice - Delgado 84

Delgado Richard "The imperial scholar Reflections on a review of civil rights literature" University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1323 (1984) 561-578

It does notno such tradition23

Impacts
I VTL

Racism destroys self-worth and dignity of those attacked Post 91
ROBERT C POST - Professor of Law School of Law (Boalt Hall) University of California at Berkeley BA Harvard College 1969 JD Yale University 1977 PhD Harvard University 1980 RACIST SPEECH DEMOCRACY AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT William and Mary Law Review 1991 httpscholarshiplawwmeducgiviewcontentcgiarticle=1924context=wmlr JJN
C Harm to Individualsits abusive nature3 9

I Marketplace of Ideas
Racism harms the marketplace of ideas turns the AC Post 91
ROBERT C POST - Professor of Law School of Law (Boalt Hall) University of California at Berkeley BA Harvard College 1969 JD Yale University 1977 PhD Harvard University 1980 RACIST SPEECH DEMOCRACY AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT William and Mary Law Review 1991 httpscholarshiplawwmeducgiviewcontentcgiarticle=1924context=wmlr JJN
D Harm to thestigmatizing victim groups

I Deontology
Racism is rejected by deontic ideals Post 91
ROBERT C POST - Professor of Law School of Law (Boalt Hall) University of California at Berkeley BA Harvard College 1969 JD Yale University 1977 PhD Harvard University 1980 RACIST SPEECH DEMOCRACY AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT William and Mary Law Review 1991 httpscholarshiplawwmeducgiviewcontentcgiarticle=1924context=wmlr JJN
A The Intrinsic Harmof racial inferiority"25

I Education
Racism interferes with and harms education Post 91
ROBERT C POST - Professor of Law School of Law (Boalt Hall) University of California at Berkeley BA Harvard College 1969 JD Yale University 1977 PhD Harvard University 1980 RACIST SPEECH DEMOCRACY AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT William and Mary Law Review 1991 httpscholarshiplawwmeducgiviewcontentcgiarticle=1924context=wmlr JJN
E Harm to Educationalseek to instill5

Opponent: NA | Judge: NA

Byrne J Peter Associate Professor Georgetown University Law Center "Racial Insults and Free Speech Within the University" Geo LJ 79 (1990) 399

This article examinesand informed judgment 3

The counterplan establishes checks on reverse enforcement chilling effect and slippery slope Byrne 91

Byrne J Peter Associate Professor Georgetown University Law Center "Racial Insults and Free Speech Within the University" Geo LJ 79 (1990) 399

Disciplinary rules areand hurtful ranting
Hate speech degrades minorities locking in the squo and ensuring their failure Delgado 2k
Richard Delgado - Charles Inglis Thomson Professor of Law University of Colorado JD U California-Berkeley 1974 TOWARD A LEGAL REALIST VIEW OF THE FIRST AMENDMENT Harvard Law Review January 2000 JJN
B Hate Speech asacross large groups
And hate speech primes society for genocide multiple empirical examples prove Tsesis 09
Tsesis Alexander Loyola University Chicago School of Law "Dignity and speech The regulation of hate speech in a democracy" (2009)
Permitting persons orprinciples of democracy
Framing
Racism must be the starting point of our evaluation without directly addressing it other moral ideals fail to have meaning because unconscious forms of racism filter into the way people see the world We cannot use idealism Bell 92
Derrick Bell Weld Professor of Law Harvard University Law School Visiting Professor New York University Law School 1991-92 school year RACIAL REALISM Connecticut Law Review Winter 1992 httpliberalartsiupuiedumpsgEssaysBell20-20Racial20Realismpdf JJN
As a veteranis never overcome

Thus the standard is resisting racism
A refusal to recognize the way race effects free speech downplay the importance of racism and should lose them this debate Lopez 03

Lpez Gerardo R University of Utah Salt Lake City "The (racially neutral) politics of education A critical race theory perspective" Educational Administration Quarterly 391 (2003) 68-94

How could Schattschneiderlarger social order
Harassment DA
Title IX investigations are increasing Kingkade 16
Tyler Kingkade There Are Far More Title IX Investigations Of Colleges Than Most People Know Huffington Post June 16 2016 httpwwwhuffingtonpostcomentrytitle-ix-investigations-sexual-harassmentus575f4b0ee4b053d433061b3d AGM
The growing backlogofficial told HuffPost
The AFF guts effectiveness of Title IX it explodes first amendment opportunism for harassment cases Marcus 08

Kenneth Marcus Higher Education Harassment and First Amendment Opportunism William Mary Bill of Rights Journal Vol 16 Issue 4 2008 NS

In one classicFirst Amendment opportunism

Title IX is currently effective against harassment this dramatically increases access to higher education Musil 07

Caryn Musil Scaling the Ivory Towers MS Magazine Fall 2007 The Triumphs of Title IX httpwwwfeministorgeducationTriumphsOfTitleIXpdf NS

The contrast betweendominated by men

Gender equality in higher education and the workforce is key to climate science and innovation Gender Summit 13

Gender Summit 3 North America Diversity Fueling Excellence in Research and Innovation
Conference Report 111313 httpswwwnsfgovodoiaactivitiesgendersummitGS3-ConfReportpdf NS

Ms Jarrett notedequality he stated

Climate innovations are the primary key to solve warming Moniz 15

Ernest Moniz (US Secretary of Energy) Interviewed by David Biello Accelerated Innovation Is the Ultimate Solution to Climate Change Scientific American 121115 httpswwwscientificamericancomarticleaccelerated-innovation-is-the-ultimate-solution-to-climate-change NS

PARISFrom "clean coal"a widespread technology
Warming leads to extinction multiple scenarios prove Roberts 13
David Roberts - staff writer for Grist If you arent alarmed about climate you arent paying attention Grist January 10 2013 httpgristorgclimate-energyclimate-alarmism-the-idea-is-surreal JJN
There was recentlyalarm is adequate

To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.

Cites

Entry	Date
NA Tournament: NA \| Round: 1 \| Opponent: NA \| Judge: NA N/A	3/17/17

Entry

Date

NA

3/17/17

Open Source

Filename	Date	Uploaded By	Delete
Harvard Westlake-Le-Neg-NA-Round1.html	3/17/17	alee4@hwemailcom

Filename

Date

Uploaded By

Delete

Harvard Westlake-Le-Neg-NA-Round1.html

3/17/17

alee4@hwemailcom

delete

Add/Modify Entry

Modify a Round Add a New Round

Select a currently entered round to modify:

Tournament:
Round:

Opponent:
Judge:

Please fill out a round report below. Include information about the 1AC, 1NC, block strategy, 2NR, notable aff tricks, etc.

Round Report:

Enter cites from this debate below, with a title describing the argument. You can create more than one "entry" per round, to help keep things organized. You should NOT paste full text cards here, only cites - if you want to disclose open source, upload a document on the next page as well.

IMPORTANT NOTE: The Cites box will only accept unformatted text. Wiki syntax (e.g. from Verbatim), is strongly preferred.

Entry Title:

IMPORTANT NOTE: Your file will automatically be re-named on upload based on the provided info.

You can only upload one combined open source speech doc per round - uploading a new file will overwrite the old one.

Computed file name:

You're about to submit the following information:

After clicking "Add Entry", be patient! The page will automatically reload when your info has uploaded. If you navigate away from the page before it reloads, info may be lost.

Note: By submitting to the wiki, you grant the right for the information to be freely displayed, reproduced and archived.

Tags:

Created by Angela Lee on 2017/03/17 17:23

History

Harvard Westlake Le Neg

Cites

NA

Open Source

Add/Modify Entry

Quick Links

Schools