Harvard Westlake Berliin Aff

Version 5.1 by William Berlin on 2016/11/05 22:50

Tournament	Round	Opponent	Judge	Cites	Round Report	Open Source	Edit/Delete
Damus	1	Loyola AO	Hailey Hansen

Tournament

Round

Opponent

Judge

Cites

Round Report

Open Source

Edit/Delete

Damus

Loyola AO

Hailey Hansen

emoticon_unhappy

report

pencil delete

Tournament	Round	Report
Damus	1	Opponent: Loyola AO \| Judge: Hailey Hansen He read court clog and cap

Tournament

Round

Report

Damus

Opponent: Loyola AO | Judge: Hailey Hansen

To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.

Cites

Entry	Date
NovDec - Aff - Police State Aff Tournament: Damus \| Round: 1 \| Opponent: Loyola AO \| Judge: Hailey Hansen Part 1 is Framework The starting point of government deliberation has to be the individual and how they relate to the social world around them. Rules only gain their force if they are open to public criticism. This means we need a procedural democracy that transcends the exact content of any moral rule. . Adorno: Adorno, Theodor. "Education after Auschwitz," Critical Model Since the possibility …characters, namely schizoids. Government action is about the process of deliberation not finding an exact rule to follow in every circumstance. Generation of values requires the ability to speak out. . Singer 84 Singer, Joseph William. "The player and the cards: nihilism and legal theory." The Yale Law Journal 94.1 (1984): 1-70. Moreover, we cannot … alternative social arrangements.'85 Part 2 – The Police State Qualified immunity reflects a culture of policing that justifies terrorizing black neighborhoods and lets police know they can get away with anything. Carter ‘15 Tom Carter – WSWS Legal Correspondent, a lawyer (https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2014/02/24/cart-f24.html). "US Supreme Court Expands Immunity for Killer Cops." Center for Research on Globalization. November 12, 2015. http://www.globalresearch.ca/us-supreme-court-expands-immunity-for-killer-cops/5488366 JJN When a civil … working class opposition. Qualified immunity makes questions of civil rights irrelevant. It shuts down democratic debates about which rights we should value and prevents forms of activism that fight for legal recognition. Hassel ‘99 Diana Hassel - Associate Professor, Roger Williams University School of Law. B.A. 1979, Mount Holyoke College; J.D. 1985, Rutgers, the State University of New JerseyNewark. "Living a Lie: The Cost of Qualified Immunity." Missouri Law Review. Winter 1999. http://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3402andcontext=mlr JJN IV. THE COST OF … tools required for reform. Excessive force is the worst manifestation of this form of structural violence – 4^th amendment cases get shut down before they even have a chance. Jeffries ‘13 Jeffries Jr, John C - David and Mary Harrison Distinguished Professor of Law, the University of Virginia. "The Liability Rule for Constitutional Torts." Virginia Law Review (2013): 207-270. Finally, special mention … sufficiently similar facts. Part 3 - The plan The Supreme Court of the United States will limit qualified immunity by altering the ‘clearly established’ element of qualified immunity to be merely whether it was unconstitutional in civil suits claiming a violation of the 4^th amendment due to excessive force. Wright ‘15 Sam Wright is … established in the courts? The AFF changes police behavior – lawsuits are used by departments to create reform and individuals know their behavior will be watched – they don’t’ even need to win the lawsuits. Schwartz 10 Schwartz, Joanna. "What Police Learn from Lawsuits." Cardozo Law Review, 2010. http://law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/default/files/event/265497/media/slspublic/What'Police'Learn'From'Lawsuits.pdf. SGK Lawsuits are widely …of information."253 The AFF changes culture – it is a form of social condemnation that validates the claims of the survivor. Armacost 98 Armacost 98 Barbara Armacost, Vanderbilt Law Review, April, 1998, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract'id=90852, "Qualified Immunity: Ignorance Excused," WP** If constitutional rights …clear constitutional impropriety.	11/5/16

Entry

Date

NovDec - Aff - Police State Aff

Tournament: Damus | Round: 1 | Opponent: Loyola AO | Judge: Hailey Hansen

Part 1 is Framework

The starting point of government deliberation has to be the individual and how they relate to the social world around them. Rules only gain their force if they are open to public criticism. This means we need a procedural democracy that transcends the exact content of any moral rule. . Adorno:

Adorno, Theodor. "Education after Auschwitz," Critical Model

Since the possibility …characters, namely schizoids.

Government action is about the process of deliberation not finding an exact rule to follow in every circumstance. Generation of values requires the ability to speak out. . Singer 84

Singer, Joseph William. "The player and the cards: nihilism and legal theory." The Yale Law Journal 94.1 (1984): 1-70.

Moreover, we cannot … alternative social arrangements.'85

Part 2 – The Police State

Qualified immunity reflects a culture of policing that justifies terrorizing black neighborhoods and lets police know they can get away with anything. Carter ‘15

Tom Carter – WSWS Legal Correspondent, a lawyer (https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2014/02/24/cart-f24.html). "US Supreme Court Expands Immunity for Killer Cops." Center for Research on Globalization. November 12, 2015. http://www.globalresearch.ca/us-supreme-court-expands-immunity-for-killer-cops/5488366 JJN
When a civil … working class opposition.

Qualified immunity makes questions of civil rights irrelevant. It shuts down democratic debates about which rights we should value and prevents forms of activism that fight for legal recognition. Hassel ‘99

Diana Hassel - Associate Professor, Roger Williams University School of Law. B.A. 1979, Mount Holyoke College; J.D. 1985, Rutgers, the State University of New JerseyNewark. "Living a Lie: The Cost of Qualified Immunity." Missouri Law Review. Winter 1999. http://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3402andcontext=mlr JJN

IV. THE COST OF … tools required for reform.

Excessive force is the worst manifestation of this form of structural violence – 4^th amendment cases get shut down before they even have a chance. Jeffries ‘13

Jeffries Jr, John C - David and Mary Harrison Distinguished Professor of Law, the University of Virginia. "The Liability Rule for Constitutional Torts." Virginia Law Review (2013): 207-270.
Finally, special mention … sufficiently similar facts.

Part 3 - The plan

The Supreme Court of the United States will limit qualified immunity by altering the ‘clearly established’ element of qualified immunity to be merely whether it was unconstitutional in civil suits claiming a violation of the 4^th amendment due to excessive force. Wright ‘15

Sam Wright is … established in the courts?

The AFF changes police behavior – lawsuits are used by departments to create reform and individuals know their behavior will be watched – they don’t’ even need to win the lawsuits. Schwartz 10

Schwartz, Joanna. "What Police Learn from Lawsuits." Cardozo Law Review, 2010. http://law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/default/files/event/265497/media/slspublic/What'Police'Learn'From'Lawsuits.pdf**. SGK
Lawsuits are widely …of information."253

The AFF changes culture – it is a form of social condemnation that validates the claims of the survivor. Armacost 98

Armacost 98 Barbara Armacost, Vanderbilt Law Review, April, 1998, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract'id=90852, "Qualified Immunity: Ignorance Excused," WP

If constitutional rights …clear constitutional impropriety.

11/5/16

Open Source

Filename

Date

Uploaded By

Delete

Add/Modify Entry

Modify a Round Add a New Round

Select a currently entered round to modify:

Tournament:
Round:

Opponent:
Judge:

Please fill out a round report below. Include information about the 1AC, 1NC, block strategy, 2NR, notable aff tricks, etc.

Round Report:

Enter cites from this debate below, with a title describing the argument. You can create more than one "entry" per round, to help keep things organized. You should NOT paste full text cards here, only cites - if you want to disclose open source, upload a document on the next page as well.

IMPORTANT NOTE: The Cites box will only accept unformatted text. Wiki syntax (e.g. from Verbatim), is strongly preferred.

Entry Title:

IMPORTANT NOTE: Your file will automatically be re-named on upload based on the provided info.

You can only upload one combined open source speech doc per round - uploading a new file will overwrite the old one.

Computed file name:

You're about to submit the following information:

After clicking "Add Entry", be patient! The page will automatically reload when your info has uploaded. If you navigate away from the page before it reloads, info may be lost.

Note: By submitting to the wiki, you grant the right for the information to be freely displayed, reproduced and archived.

Tags:

Created by Scott Phillips on 2016/11/04 23:16

History

Harvard Westlake Berliin Aff

Cites

NovDec - Aff - Police State Aff

Part 1 is Framework

The starting point of government deliberation has to be the individual and how they relate to the social world around them. Rules only gain their force if they are open to public criticism. This means we need a procedural democracy that transcends the exact content of any moral rule. . Adorno:

Government action is about the process of deliberation not finding an exact rule to follow in every circumstance. Generation of values requires the ability to speak out. . Singer 84

Part 2 – The Police State

Qualified immunity reflects a culture of policing that justifies terrorizing black neighborhoods and lets police know they can get away with anything. Carter ‘15

Qualified immunity makes questions of civil rights irrelevant. It shuts down democratic debates about which rights we should value and prevents forms of activism that fight for legal recognition. Hassel ‘99

Excessive force is the worst manifestation of this form of structural violence – 4^th amendment cases get shut down before they even have a chance. Jeffries ‘13

Part 3 - The plan

The Supreme Court of the United States will limit qualified immunity by altering the ‘clearly established’ element of qualified immunity to be merely whether it was unconstitutional in civil suits claiming a violation of the 4^th amendment due to excessive force. Wright ‘15

The AFF changes police behavior – lawsuits are used by departments to create reform and individuals know their behavior will be watched – they don’t’ even need to win the lawsuits. Schwartz 10

The AFF changes culture – it is a form of social condemnation that validates the claims of the survivor. Armacost 98

Open Source

Add/Modify Entry

Quick Links

Schools

Harvard Westlake Berliin Aff

Cites

NovDec - Aff - Police State Aff

Part 1 is Framework

The starting point of government deliberation has to be the individual and how they relate to the social world around them. Rules only gain their force if they are open to public criticism. This means we need a procedural democracy that transcends the exact content of any moral rule. . Adorno:

Government action is about the process of deliberation not finding an exact rule to follow in every circumstance. Generation of values requires the ability to speak out. . Singer 84

Part 2 – The Police State

Qualified immunity reflects a culture of policing that justifies terrorizing black neighborhoods and lets police know they can get away with anything. Carter ‘15

Qualified immunity makes questions of civil rights irrelevant. It shuts down democratic debates about which rights we should value and prevents forms of activism that fight for legal recognition. Hassel ‘99

Excessive force is the worst manifestation of this form of structural violence – 4th amendment cases get shut down before they even have a chance. Jeffries ‘13

Part 3 - The plan

The Supreme Court of the United States will limit qualified immunity by altering the ‘clearly established’ element of qualified immunity to be merely whether it was unconstitutional in civil suits claiming a violation of the 4th amendment due to excessive force. Wright ‘15

The AFF changes police behavior – lawsuits are used by departments to create reform and individuals know their behavior will be watched – they don’t’ even need to win the lawsuits. Schwartz 10

The AFF changes culture – it is a form of social condemnation that validates the claims of the survivor. Armacost 98

Open Source

Add/Modify Entry

Quick Links

Schools

Excessive force is the worst manifestation of this form of structural violence – 4^th amendment cases get shut down before they even have a chance. Jeffries ‘13

The Supreme Court of the United States will limit qualified immunity by altering the ‘clearly established’ element of qualified immunity to be merely whether it was unconstitutional in civil suits claiming a violation of the 4^th amendment due to excessive force. Wright ‘15