To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.
Cites
Entry
Date
1- EM Plans Bad
Tournament: Loyola | Round: Quarters | Opponent: Mountain View DZ | Judge: Panel A is the Interpretation: If the aff defends an epistemically modest paradigm of framework debate, then they must defend the whole resolution. To clarify, either epistemic modesty or a plan is permissible but the combination isn’t.
9/21/16
1- MPA Bad
Tournament: Loyola | Round: Semis | Opponent: La Cnada AZ | Judge: Panel A is the Interpretation: debaters reading causal link chains must either defend all links with pure analytics or read a link chain advocate who claims a causal connection from the initial link, e.g. the point of divergence between the aff and neg worlds, to the terminal impact. To clarify, they cannot have one author saying that X will lead to Y and another author saying Y will lead to Z.
9/21/16
1- Must Read Fwk
Tournament: Loyola | Round: 2 | Opponent: Polytechnic JL | Judge: Adam Bistagne A is the Interpretation: the affirmative debater must link all offense to a comprehensive normative theory that entails the truth or falsity of all normative propositions, rather than a) linking to some narrow principle without explaining what broader theory justifies it or b) linking to a broad theory they don’t justify. Their moral framework cannot just appeal to a feature they purport to be demanded or appealed to by all moral theories; rather, it must be derived from a single theory.
9/21/16
SO Crap K
Tournament: Loyola | Round: 4 | Opponent: Harvard-Westlake CE | Judge: Kris Kaya A is the Link: Affirming necessarily pushes energy into the private sector. The privatization of services expands neoliberal forms of biopower via capitalism – even if nuclear power is biopolitical, the aff is way worse. Hamann in 2k9 (Trent, St. John’s University, Foucault Studes no 6, Neoliberalism, Governmentality, and Ethics, http://rauli.cbs.dk/index.php/foucault-studies/article/view/2471/2469) Within this formerly public ... onto individuals has succeeded. Countries require reliable energy to meet base-load capacity – a nuclear energy ban only leads to reliance on coal - other fuels aren’t viable. Bosselman 7, Fred. (Professor of Law Emeritus, Chicago-Kent College of Law. Professor Bosselman is not affiliated with any company or agency that promotes nuclear power.) THE ECOLOGICAL ADVANTAGES OF NUCLEAR POWER. 3/15/2007. NP 8/24/16. in substitution DA The coal industry is horribly exploitative and unsafe—it’s corrupt to lower prices to meet international energy markets. Clark 14 Poor Working Conditions Continue To Plague Coal-Producing Developing Countries BY MEAGAN CLARK(staff reporter) 05/14/14 AT 3:21 PM http://www.ibtimes.com/poor-working-conditions-continue-plague-coal-producing-developing-countries-1584359 IB Times NS 8/27 Coal miners around ... Non-Traditional Security Studies report concluded. Coal is worse: horrible for minority communities and lower-income areas. Israel 12 Coal plants smothering communities of color, report finds By Brett Israel (Scientific American Environmental Health Contributor) The Daily Climate http://www.dailyclimate.org/tdc-newsroom/2012/11/coal-power-injustice Nov 26, 2012 NS 8/26/12 Coal plants place a disproportionate ... according to the report. B is the Impact: No value to life under capitalism—it reduces everything to consumerist decision calculus. Cerni 07 Cerni, cultural logic electronic collection of Marxist Theory and Practice independent writer, 07 (Paula, “The Age of Consumer Capitalism”, http://clogic.eserver.org/2007/Cerni.pdf, accessed 7/8/09, JD) Thus the powerlessness ... intangible flows of information and knowledge. This also outweighs their impacts since even if they solve, we have no value to life to enjoy them in the first place. Class focus and capitalism come before all impacts and is the root cause of all oppression. Kovel 07 Kovel, Prof. of Social Studies @ Bard, 2007 Joel, “The Enemy of Nature”, p. 140- If, however, we ask the ... discuss in the next section. Part C: the alt is to empower nuclear workers to socialize nuclear power. A rejection of nuclear power is impractical and doesn’t solve—it pushed power back into the hands of new government agencies and corporations. Only an empowerment movement solves. King ‘11 FUKUSHIMA, THE LEFT, AND NUCLEAR POWER by Stuart King on Socialist Arguments for Nuclear Power June 14, 2011. http://climateandcapitalism.com/2011/06/14/socialist-arguments-for-nuclear-power/ Climate and Capitalism Cut 9/3 NS The whole of the nuclear ... technicians to be able to do so.
9/11/16
SO Environmental Apocalypticism K
Tournament: Loyola | Round: 2 | Opponent: Polytechnic JL | Judge: Adam Bistagne Claims of catastrophe claims don’t motivate – they alienate and force reactionary policies that result in eco-fascism. Turning away form apocalyptic rhetoric is key to addressing environmental problems in a meaningful way. Davidson, 2000 BioScience 50(5):433-440. 2000 Economic Growth and the Environment:Alternatives to the Limits Paradigm CARLOS DAVIDSON Carlos Davidson is a conservation biologist with a background in economics. He is currently studying landscape-scale patterns of amphibian decline in California in the Section of Evolution and Ecology, University of California, Davis Is the limits metaphor ... and might support change? Eco-fascism decimates the human population and accelerates degradation. Lewis, 94 Martin Lewis, 1994. Lecturer in history and director of the International Relations program at Stanford. Green Delusions, p. 8, Google Books. Finally, the radical green movement ... in an already industrialized society. The alternative is to reject the affirmative in order to oppose their representations of the environment and replace them with the metaphor of the tapestry of nature. Representing environmental degradation in terms of passing limits that risk catastrophic collapse is a political manipulation that is not based in science. Degradation is more akin to the slow unraveling of the tapestry of nature—that is a better way to craft and understand environmental policy. Davidson, 2000 BioScience 50(5):433-440. 2000 Economic Growth and the Environment:Alternatives to the Limits Paradigm CARLOS DAVIDSON Carlos Davidson is a conservation biologist with a background in economics. He is currently studying landscape-scale patterns of amphibian decline in California in the Section of Evolution and Ecology, University of California, Davis The relationship between ... option, and amenity considerations. Political method is a prior question to the aff—the impact is serial policy failure. Dillon and Reid 2K (Michael and Julian, “Global Governance, Liberal Peace, and Complex Emergency,” Alternatives: Social Transformation and Humane Governance, Jan-Mar 2000, Vol. 25, Issue 1, Ebsco) As a precursor to global ... as Foucauldian "biopower" ways.
9/10/16
SO HW Interp
Tournament: Loyola | Round: Octas | Opponent: HW IP | Judge: Panel Affirmative debaters may not defend a phase-out. They must defend that nuclear power plants are immediately dismantled, not phased out.
