Chaminade Cha Aff

Version 12.1 by Leo Kim on 2016/09/10 23:18

Tournament	Round	Opponent	Judge	Cites	Round Report	Open Source	Edit/Delete
Loyola	2	Cajon IC	Li-Ren Chang
Loyola	4	Brentwood RY	Michael OKrent

Tournament

Round

Opponent

Judge

Cites

Round Report

Open Source

Edit/Delete

Loyola

Cajon IC

Li-Ren Chang

tick

report

pencil delete

Loyola

Brentwood RY

Michael OKrent

tick

pencil delete

Tournament	Round	Report
Loyola	2	Opponent: Cajon IC \| Judge: Li-Ren Chang 1AC - Enviro Prolif

Tournament

Round

Report

Loyola

Opponent: Cajon IC | Judge: Li-Ren Chang

To modify or delete round reports, edit the associated round.

Cites

Entry	Date
Sept-Oct 1AC - Defend the Resolution Plz - Loyola - Round 1 Tournament: Loyola \| Round: 2 \| Opponent: Cajon IC \| Judge: Li-Ren Chang 1AC – Framework Value: Utilitarianism Value Criterion: Lives saved Extinction first—existence before essence Paul Wapner, Associate Professor and Director, Global Environmental Policy Program, American University, "Leftist Criticism of 'Nature': Environmental Protection in a Postmodern Age," DISSENT, Winter 2003, www.dissentmagazine.org/menutest/archives/2003/wi03/wapner.htm All attempts to listen to nature are social constructions-except one. Even the AND , they deny their own intellectual insights and compromise their fundamental moral commitment. Extinction is possible – their authors underestimate the risk Anderson 12 (Ross Anderson, deputy director of Aeon Magazine, "We're Underestimating the Risk of Human Extinction", The Atlantic, March 2012, http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/03/were-underestimating-the-risk-of-human-extinction/253821/) Unthinkable as it may be, humanity, every last person, could someday be AND , and about what we can do to make sure we outlast them. Prioritize existence because value is subjective and could improve in the future Torbjörn Tännsjö 11, the Kristian Claëson Professor of Practical Philosophy at Stockholm University, 2011, "Shalt Thou Sometimes Murder? On the Ethics of Killing," online: http://people.su.se/~~jolso/HS-texter/shaltthou.pdf I suppose it is correct to say that, if Schopenhauer is right, if AND suffering (in their lives) than I avoid (in my life). Utilitarianism inevitable even in deontological frameworks Green, 02 – Assistant Professor Department of Psychology Harvard University (Joshua, November 2002 "The Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Truth About Morality And What To Do About It", 314) Some people who talk of balancing rights may think there is an algorithm for deciding AND represents is either dogmatic in an esoteric sort of way or covertly consequentialist. 1AC – Plan The United States federal government should prohibit its production of nuclear energy. 1AC – Environment Advantage one is the environment – Scenario one is ocean biodiversity – Nuclear Power destroys ocean biodiversity and marine habitats Gunter 99 (Linda, Safe Energy Communication Council, Licensed to Kill: How the nuclear power industry destroys endangered marine wildlife and ocean habitat to save money, 1999, http://www.nirs.org/reactorwatch/licensedtokill/LiscencedtoKill.pdf) Marine life in all forms, from endangered manatees and sea turtles to essential microscopic AND weakened, watered down, or done away with entirely at nuclear reactors. Collapse of marine ecosystems lead to extinction Craig 3 - Attorneys' Title Professor of Law and Associate Dean for Environmental Programs at Florida State University (Robin Kundis Craig, "ARTICLE: Taking Steps Toward Marine Wilderness Protection? Fishing and Coral Reef Marine Reserves in Florida and Hawaii," McGeorge Law Review, Winter 2003, 34 McGeorge L. Rev. 155) Biodiversity and ecosystem function arguments for conserving marine ecosystems also exist, just as they AND its territory relatively pristine marine ecosystems that may be unique in the world. 1AC – Proliferation Massive expansion of nuclear power's inevitable worldwide – that causes cascading prolif John P Banks and Charles K Ebinger 11, John is a fellow with the Energy Security Initiative at the Brookings Institution, Charles is senior fellow and director of the Energy Security Initiative at the Brookings Institution, "Introduction: Planning a Responsible Nuclear Future" in "Business and Nonproliferation", googlebooks Nuclear energy is a twentieth-century innovation but until recently has not spread beyond AND reprocessing. This is a major challenge for a regime already under stress. Two internal links: First, the spread of enrichment and reprocessing collapse the entire nonproliferation regime Anatoly S. Diyakov 10, Professor of Physics and Director of the Center for Arms Control Energy and Environmental Studies at the Moscow Institute of Physics, "The nuclear "renaissance" and preventing the spread of enrichment and reprocessing technologies: a Russian view", Dædalus Winter 2010 The anticipated growth of nuclear power around the world may lead to the spread of AND countries guaranteed access to external sources of nuclear fuel cycle services and products. Second, reprocessing leads to prolif – lack of nuclear assurance. Bengelsdorf 7 — Harold Bengelsdorf, consultant and former director of both key State and Energy Department offices that are concerned with international nuclear and nonproliferation affairs, 07 ~"THE U.S. DOMESTIC CIVIL NUCLEAR INFRASTRUCTURE AND U.S. NONPROLIFERATION POLICY", White Paper prepared for the American Council on Global Nuclear Competitiveness May, http://www.nuclearcompetitiveness.org/images/COUNCIL_WHITE_PAPER_Final.pdf~~ Thus in recent years attention has largely focused on the risks of proliferation associated with AND fuel assurances in order to discourage countries from building enrichment and reprocessing facilities. Squo nuclear power means quick breakout—asymmetric development of arsenals creates imbalances that undermine deterrent relationships Sokolski 9 Henry Sokolski, Executive Director of the Nonproliferation Policy Education Center, 6/1/2009, Avoiding a Nuclear Crowd, http://www.hoover.org/publications/policy-review/article/5534 Finally, several new nuclear weapons contenders are also likely to emerge in the next AND , would ever want. None of this, however, is inevitable. Prolif cascades cause militarization of disputes—escalates to great power war Kroenig 9 Matt Kroenig, assistant professor of Government at Georgetown University and a Stanton Nuclear Security Fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, November 2009, Beyond Optimism and Pessimism: The Differential Effects of Nuclear Proliferation, http://belfercenter.hks.harvard.edu/publication/19671/beyond_optimism_and_pessimism.html Nuclear proliferation can embolden new nuclear states, triggering regional instability that could potentially threaten AND another dangerous flash-point in the uncertain Sino-American strategic relationship. Cold War no longer applies—nuclear war is the reality Cimbala 8 Stephen Cimbala, Ph.D., Penn State Brandywine Political Science Distinguished Professor, 2008, Anticipatory Attacks: Nuclear Crisis Stability in Future Asia, Comparative Strategy Volume 27, Issue 2 The spread of nuclear weapons in Asia presents a complicated mosaic of possibilities in this AND concepts might be inaccurate guides to the avoidance of war outside of Europe.	9/10/16
Sept-Oct 1AC - Defend the Resolution Plz - Loyola - Round 4 Tournament: Loyola \| Round: 4 \| Opponent: Brentwood RY \| Judge: Michael OKrent 1AC – Framework Value: Utilitarianism Value Criterion: Lives saved Extinction first—existence before essence Paul Wapner, Associate Professor and Director, Global Environmental Policy Program, American University, "Leftist Criticism of 'Nature': Environmental Protection in a Postmodern Age," DISSENT, Winter 2003, www.dissentmagazine.org/menutest/archives/2003/wi03/wapner.htm All attempts to listen to nature are social constructions-except one. Even the AND , they deny their own intellectual insights and compromise their fundamental moral commitment. Extinction is possible – their authors underestimate the risk Anderson 12 (Ross Anderson, deputy director of Aeon Magazine, "We're Underestimating the Risk of Human Extinction", The Atlantic, March 2012, http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/03/were-underestimating-the-risk-of-human-extinction/253821/) Unthinkable as it may be, humanity, every last person, could someday be AND , and about what we can do to make sure we outlast them. Prioritize existence because value is subjective and could improve in the future Torbjörn Tännsjö 11, the Kristian Claëson Professor of Practical Philosophy at Stockholm University, 2011, "Shalt Thou Sometimes Murder? On the Ethics of Killing," online: http://people.su.se/~~jolso/HS-texter/shaltthou.pdf I suppose it is correct to say that, if Schopenhauer is right, if AND suffering (in their lives) than I avoid (in my life). Utilitarianism inevitable even in deontological frameworks Green, 02 – Assistant Professor Department of Psychology Harvard University (Joshua, November 2002 "The Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Truth About Morality And What To Do About It", 314) Some people who talk of balancing rights may think there is an algorithm for deciding AND represents is either dogmatic in an esoteric sort of way or covertly consequentialist. 1AC – Plan The United States federal government should prohibit its production of nuclear energy. 1AC – Environment Advantage one is the environment – Scenario one is ocean biodiversity – Nuclear Power destroys ocean biodiversity and marine habitats Gunter 99 (Linda, Safe Energy Communication Council, Licensed to Kill: How the nuclear power industry destroys endangered marine wildlife and ocean habitat to save money, 1999, http://www.nirs.org/reactorwatch/licensedtokill/LiscencedtoKill.pdf) Marine life in all forms, from endangered manatees and sea turtles to essential microscopic AND weakened, watered down, or done away with entirely at nuclear reactors. Collapse of marine ecosystems lead to extinction Craig 3 - Attorneys' Title Professor of Law and Associate Dean for Environmental Programs at Florida State University (Robin Kundis Craig, "ARTICLE: Taking Steps Toward Marine Wilderness Protection? Fishing and Coral Reef Marine Reserves in Florida and Hawaii," McGeorge Law Review, Winter 2003, 34 McGeorge L. Rev. 155) Biodiversity and ecosystem function arguments for conserving marine ecosystems also exist, just as they AND its territory relatively pristine marine ecosystems that may be unique in the world. 1AC – Proliferation Massive expansion of nuclear power's inevitable worldwide – that causes cascading prolif John P Banks and Charles K Ebinger 11, John is a fellow with the Energy Security Initiative at the Brookings Institution, Charles is senior fellow and director of the Energy Security Initiative at the Brookings Institution, "Introduction: Planning a Responsible Nuclear Future" in "Business and Nonproliferation", googlebooks Nuclear energy is a twentieth-century innovation but until recently has not spread beyond AND reprocessing. This is a major challenge for a regime already under stress. Two internal links: First, the spread of enrichment and reprocessing collapse the entire nonproliferation regime Anatoly S. Diyakov 10, Professor of Physics and Director of the Center for Arms Control Energy and Environmental Studies at the Moscow Institute of Physics, "The nuclear "renaissance" and preventing the spread of enrichment and reprocessing technologies: a Russian view", Dædalus Winter 2010 The anticipated growth of nuclear power around the world may lead to the spread of AND countries guaranteed access to external sources of nuclear fuel cycle services and products. Second, reprocessing leads to prolif – lack of nuclear assurance. Bengelsdorf 7 — Harold Bengelsdorf, consultant and former director of both key State and Energy Department offices that are concerned with international nuclear and nonproliferation affairs, 07 ~"THE U.S. DOMESTIC CIVIL NUCLEAR INFRASTRUCTURE AND U.S. NONPROLIFERATION POLICY", White Paper prepared for the American Council on Global Nuclear Competitiveness May, http://www.nuclearcompetitiveness.org/images/COUNCIL_WHITE_PAPER_Final.pdf~~ Thus in recent years attention has largely focused on the risks of proliferation associated with AND fuel assurances in order to discourage countries from building enrichment and reprocessing facilities. Squo nuclear power means quick breakout—asymmetric development of arsenals creates imbalances that undermine deterrent relationships Sokolski 9 Henry Sokolski, Executive Director of the Nonproliferation Policy Education Center, 6/1/2009, Avoiding a Nuclear Crowd, http://www.hoover.org/publications/policy-review/article/5534 Finally, several new nuclear weapons contenders are also likely to emerge in the next AND , would ever want. None of this, however, is inevitable. Prolif cascades cause militarization of disputes—escalates to great power war Kroenig 9 Matt Kroenig, assistant professor of Government at Georgetown University and a Stanton Nuclear Security Fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, November 2009, Beyond Optimism and Pessimism: The Differential Effects of Nuclear Proliferation, http://belfercenter.hks.harvard.edu/publication/19671/beyond_optimism_and_pessimism.html Nuclear proliferation can embolden new nuclear states, triggering regional instability that could potentially threaten AND another dangerous flash-point in the uncertain Sino-American strategic relationship. Cold War no longer applies—nuclear war is the reality Cimbala 8 Stephen Cimbala, Ph.D., Penn State Brandywine Political Science Distinguished Professor, 2008, Anticipatory Attacks: Nuclear Crisis Stability in Future Asia, Comparative Strategy Volume 27, Issue 2 The spread of nuclear weapons in Asia presents a complicated mosaic of possibilities in this AND concepts might be inaccurate guides to the avoidance of war outside of Europe.	9/10/16

Entry

Date

Sept-Oct 1AC - Defend the Resolution Plz - Loyola - Round 1

Tournament: Loyola | Round: 2 | Opponent: Cajon IC | Judge: Li-Ren Chang

1AC – Framework

Value: Utilitarianism
Value Criterion: Lives saved

Extinction first—existence before essence

Paul Wapner, Associate Professor and Director, Global Environmental Policy Program, American University, "Leftist Criticism of 'Nature': Environmental Protection in a Postmodern Age," DISSENT, Winter 2003, www.dissentmagazine.org/menutest/archives/2003/wi03/wapner.htm
All attempts to listen to nature are social constructions-except one. Even the
AND
, they deny their own intellectual insights and compromise their fundamental moral commitment.

Extinction is possible – their authors underestimate the risk

Anderson 12 (Ross Anderson, deputy director of Aeon Magazine, "We're Underestimating the Risk of Human Extinction", The Atlantic, March 2012, http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/03/were-underestimating-the-risk-of-human-extinction/253821/)
Unthinkable as it may be, humanity, every last person, could someday be
AND
, and about what we can do to make sure we outlast them.

Prioritize existence because value is subjective and could improve in the future

Torbjörn Tännsjö 11, the Kristian Claëson Professor of Practical Philosophy at Stockholm University, 2011, "Shalt Thou Sometimes Murder? On the Ethics of Killing," online: http://people.su.se/~~jolso/HS-texter/shaltthou.pdf
I suppose it is correct to say that, if Schopenhauer is right, if
AND
suffering (in their lives) than I avoid (in my life).

Utilitarianism inevitable even in deontological frameworks

Green, 02 – Assistant Professor Department of Psychology Harvard University (Joshua, November 2002 "The Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Truth About Morality And What To Do About It", 314)
Some people who talk of balancing rights may think there is an algorithm for deciding
AND
represents is either dogmatic in an esoteric sort of way or covertly consequentialist.

1AC – Plan

The United States federal government should prohibit its production of nuclear energy.

1AC – Environment

Advantage one is the environment –

Scenario one is ocean biodiversity –

Nuclear Power destroys ocean biodiversity and marine habitats

Gunter 99 (Linda, Safe Energy Communication Council, Licensed to Kill: How the nuclear power industry destroys endangered marine wildlife and ocean habitat to save money, 1999, http://www.nirs.org/reactorwatch/licensedtokill/LiscencedtoKill.pdf)
Marine life in all forms, from endangered manatees and sea turtles to essential microscopic
AND
weakened, watered down, or done away with entirely at nuclear reactors.

Collapse of marine ecosystems lead to extinction

Craig 3 - Attorneys' Title Professor of Law and Associate Dean for Environmental Programs at Florida State University
(Robin Kundis Craig, "ARTICLE: Taking Steps Toward Marine Wilderness Protection? Fishing and Coral Reef Marine Reserves in Florida and Hawaii," McGeorge Law Review, Winter 2003, 34 McGeorge L. Rev. 155)
Biodiversity and ecosystem function arguments for conserving marine ecosystems also exist, just as they
AND
its territory relatively pristine marine ecosystems that may be unique in the world.

1AC – Proliferation

Massive expansion of nuclear power's inevitable worldwide – that causes cascading prolif

John P Banks and Charles K Ebinger 11, John is a fellow with the Energy Security Initiative at the Brookings Institution, Charles is senior fellow and director of the Energy Security Initiative at the Brookings Institution, "Introduction: Planning a Responsible Nuclear Future" in "Business and Nonproliferation", googlebooks
Nuclear energy is a twentieth-century innovation but until recently has not spread beyond
AND
reprocessing. This is a major challenge for a regime already under stress.

Two internal links:

First, the spread of enrichment and reprocessing collapse the entire nonproliferation regime

Anatoly S. Diyakov 10, Professor of Physics and Director of the Center for Arms Control Energy and Environmental Studies at the Moscow Institute of Physics, "The nuclear "renaissance" and preventing the spread of enrichment and reprocessing technologies: a Russian view", Dædalus Winter 2010
The anticipated growth of nuclear power around the world may lead to the spread of
AND
countries guaranteed access to external sources of nuclear fuel cycle services and products.

Second, reprocessing leads to prolif – lack of nuclear assurance.

Bengelsdorf 7 — Harold Bengelsdorf, consultant and former director of both key State and Energy Department offices that are concerned with international nuclear and nonproliferation affairs, 07 ~"THE U.S. DOMESTIC CIVIL NUCLEAR INFRASTRUCTURE AND U.S. NONPROLIFERATION POLICY", White Paper prepared for the American Council on Global Nuclear Competitiveness May, http://www.nuclearcompetitiveness.org/images/COUNCIL_WHITE_PAPER_Final.pdf~~
Thus in recent years attention has largely focused on the risks of proliferation associated with
AND
fuel assurances in order to discourage countries from building enrichment and reprocessing facilities.

Squo nuclear power means quick breakout—asymmetric development of arsenals creates imbalances that undermine deterrent relationships

Sokolski 9
Henry Sokolski, Executive Director of the Nonproliferation Policy Education Center, 6/1/2009, Avoiding a Nuclear Crowd, http://www.hoover.org/publications/policy-review/article/5534
Finally, several new nuclear weapons contenders are also likely to emerge in the next
AND
, would ever want. None of this, however, is inevitable.

Prolif cascades cause militarization of disputes—escalates to great power war

Kroenig 9
Matt Kroenig, assistant professor of Government at Georgetown University and a Stanton Nuclear Security Fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, November 2009, Beyond Optimism and Pessimism: The Differential Effects of Nuclear Proliferation, http://belfercenter.hks.harvard.edu/publication/19671/beyond_optimism_and_pessimism.html
Nuclear proliferation can embolden new nuclear states, triggering regional instability that could potentially threaten
AND
another dangerous flash-point in the uncertain Sino-American strategic relationship.

Cold War no longer applies—nuclear war is the reality

Cimbala 8
Stephen Cimbala, Ph.D., Penn State Brandywine Political Science Distinguished Professor, 2008, Anticipatory Attacks: Nuclear Crisis Stability in Future Asia, Comparative Strategy Volume 27, Issue 2
The spread of nuclear weapons in Asia presents a complicated mosaic of possibilities in this
AND
concepts might be inaccurate guides to the avoidance of war outside of Europe.

9/10/16

Sept-Oct 1AC - Defend the Resolution Plz - Loyola - Round 4

Tournament: Loyola | Round: 4 | Opponent: Brentwood RY | Judge: Michael OKrent

1AC – Framework

Value: Utilitarianism
Value Criterion: Lives saved

Extinction first—existence before essence

Extinction is possible – their authors underestimate the risk

Prioritize existence because value is subjective and could improve in the future

Utilitarianism inevitable even in deontological frameworks

1AC – Plan

The United States federal government should prohibit its production of nuclear energy.

1AC – Environment

Advantage one is the environment –

Scenario one is ocean biodiversity –

Nuclear Power destroys ocean biodiversity and marine habitats

Collapse of marine ecosystems lead to extinction

1AC – Proliferation

Massive expansion of nuclear power's inevitable worldwide – that causes cascading prolif

Two internal links:

First, the spread of enrichment and reprocessing collapse the entire nonproliferation regime

Second, reprocessing leads to prolif – lack of nuclear assurance.

Squo nuclear power means quick breakout—asymmetric development of arsenals creates imbalances that undermine deterrent relationships

Prolif cascades cause militarization of disputes—escalates to great power war

Cold War no longer applies—nuclear war is the reality

9/10/16

Open Source

Filename

Date

Uploaded By

Delete

Add/Modify Entry

Modify a Round Add a New Round

Select a currently entered round to modify:

Tournament:
Round:

Opponent:
Judge:

Please fill out a round report below. Include information about the 1AC, 1NC, block strategy, 2NR, notable aff tricks, etc.

Round Report:

Enter cites from this debate below, with a title describing the argument. You can create more than one "entry" per round, to help keep things organized. You should NOT paste full text cards here, only cites - if you want to disclose open source, upload a document on the next page as well.

IMPORTANT NOTE: The Cites box will only accept unformatted text. Wiki syntax (e.g. from Verbatim), is strongly preferred.

Entry Title:

IMPORTANT NOTE: Your file will automatically be re-named on upload based on the provided info.

You can only upload one combined open source speech doc per round - uploading a new file will overwrite the old one.

Computed file name:

You're about to submit the following information:

After clicking "Add Entry", be patient! The page will automatically reload when your info has uploaded. If you navigate away from the page before it reloads, info may be lost.

Note: By submitting to the wiki, you grant the right for the information to be freely displayed, reproduced and archived.

Tags:

Created by Leo Kim on 2016/09/10 18:55

History

Chaminade Cha Aff

Cites

Sept-Oct 1AC - Defend the Resolution Plz - Loyola - Round 1

1AC – Framework

Extinction first—existence before essence

Extinction is possible – their authors underestimate the risk

Prioritize existence because value is subjective and could improve in the future

Utilitarianism inevitable even in deontological frameworks

1AC – Plan

The United States federal government should prohibit its production of nuclear energy.

1AC – Environment

Advantage one is the environment –

Scenario one is ocean biodiversity –

Nuclear Power destroys ocean biodiversity and marine habitats

Collapse of marine ecosystems lead to extinction

1AC – Proliferation

Massive expansion of nuclear power's inevitable worldwide – that causes cascading prolif

Two internal links:

First, the spread of enrichment and reprocessing collapse the entire nonproliferation regime

Second, reprocessing leads to prolif – lack of nuclear assurance.

Squo nuclear power means quick breakout—asymmetric development of arsenals creates imbalances that undermine deterrent relationships

Prolif cascades cause militarization of disputes—escalates to great power war

Cold War no longer applies—nuclear war is the reality

Sept-Oct 1AC - Defend the Resolution Plz - Loyola - Round 4

1AC – Framework

Extinction first—existence before essence

Extinction is possible – their authors underestimate the risk

Prioritize existence because value is subjective and could improve in the future

Utilitarianism inevitable even in deontological frameworks

1AC – Plan

The United States federal government should prohibit its production of nuclear energy.

1AC – Environment

Advantage one is the environment –

Scenario one is ocean biodiversity –

Nuclear Power destroys ocean biodiversity and marine habitats

Collapse of marine ecosystems lead to extinction

1AC – Proliferation

Massive expansion of nuclear power's inevitable worldwide – that causes cascading prolif

Two internal links:

First, the spread of enrichment and reprocessing collapse the entire nonproliferation regime

Second, reprocessing leads to prolif – lack of nuclear assurance.

Squo nuclear power means quick breakout—asymmetric development of arsenals creates imbalances that undermine deterrent relationships

Prolif cascades cause militarization of disputes—escalates to great power war

Cold War no longer applies—nuclear war is the reality

Open Source

Add/Modify Entry

Quick Links

Schools