Tournament: harvardwestlake | Round: 6 | Opponent: X | Judge: X
Interpretation: The aff must defend all public colleges and universities and must not defend that only a single college or combination of colleges ought to remove specific speech codes.
DeBois 16 Danny; Danny DeBois (Harvard ’18) debated for Harrison High School in New York for 4 years. He won the TOC, NCFL Grand Nationals, the Minneapple, the Glenbrooks, and the Harvard Invitational (twice). As a coach at Harvard- Westlake in California, his students have won the TOC, Greenhill, the Voices Round Robin, the Kandi King Round Robin, and Loyola, reached finals of NDCA Nationals and Emory, and made the USA Debate World Schools Team; Victory Briefs Jan/Feb
Some people will find it a good idea to specify particular public colleges or universities
AND
speech, not why certain public colleges and universities should have certain procedures.
Violation:
Limits – there’s 1,699 public colleges and universities, solvency advocate doesn’t check back
DeBois 16 does the math Danny; Danny DeBois (Harvard ’18) debated for Harrison High School in New York for 4 years. He won the TOC, NCFL Grand Nationals, the Minneapple, the Glenbrooks, and the Harvard Invitational (twice). As a coach at Harvard- Westlake in California, his students have won the TOC, Greenhill, the Voices Round Robin, the Kandi King Round Robin, and Loyola, reached finals of NDCA Nationals and Emory, and made the USA Debate World Schools Team; Victory Briefs Jan/Feb
Second, an interpretation allowing specification of particular public colleges and universities is truly limitless
AND
characterized by bad theory and generic K links, don’t specify an actor.
Multiply that by the thousands of speech codes there are
Lukianoff 08 (Greg Lukianoff, "Campus Speech Codes: Absurd, Tenacious, and Everywhere", May 23, 2008 , https://www.nas.org/articles/Campus_Speech_Codes_Absurd_Tenacious_and_Everywhere)
For our 2007 report, FIRE surveyed publicly available policies at the 100 “Best
AND
to our knowledge, the most extensive evaluation of campus codes ever attempted.
Research overload has real world consequences, it’s an independent voter
Harris 13, Scott Debate coach for over 25 years, coaches University of Kansas Policy Debate Team, " This ballot," Published on CEDADebate.org Forums. 5/5/13. http://www.cedadebate.org/forum/index.php?topic=4762.msg10246
Debates about what kinds of arguments we should or should not be making in debates
AND
little to no effect on the teams that refuse to debate the topic.