| ... |
... |
@@ -1,0
+1,35 @@ |
|
1 |
+The role of the judge is to vote for the debater who provides the strategy most conducive to the process of becoming an ethical subject. |
|
2 |
+The self only forms in relation to the Other and the norms that govern our recognition of one another. |
|
3 |
+Butler 1 Butler, Judith. “Giving an Account of Oneself.” Verso Press, Berkley University. 2003. |
|
4 |
+In all the…of its use. |
|
5 |
+Dependence on the Other means self-understanding is always interrupted and must be reformed through the narratives we give ourselves—other ethical theories erase this fundamental incompleteness of the subject. |
|
6 |
+Butler 2 Butler, Judith. “Giving an Account of Oneself.” Verso Press, Berkley University. 2003. |
|
7 |
+In a sense…it is true. |
|
8 |
+Analytic |
|
9 |
+We become responsible when we suspend judgments for the other and instead work toward self-knowledge. |
|
10 |
+Butler 3 Butler, Judith. “Giving an Account of Oneself.” Verso Press, Berkley University. 2003. |
|
11 |
+So, according to…responsibility first emerges. |
|
12 |
+Since value is grounded in social norms, certain lives are recognized as grievable and thus valuable. However, other lives are cast aside by social structures and rendered ungrievable. |
|
13 |
+Butler 4 Butler, Judith. “Frames of War.” Verso Press, Berkley University. 2009. |
|
14 |
+Conditions have to…its material effects. |
|
15 |
+Thus the role of the ballot is to vote for the debater who provides the best method to recognize the grievability of life. |
|
16 |
+Additionally prefer because: |
|
17 |
+1) Agency is intersubjective—analytics |
|
18 |
+2) Side constraint—only way to account for each agent’s moral significance. |
|
19 |
+Butler 5 Judith Butler. Frames of War. Verso Press: New York, 2009. |
|
20 |
+The epistemological capacity…recognized as lives. |
|
21 |
+Analytics |
|
22 |
+I affirm that countries ought to ban the production of nuclear power. I place a demand on the state to recognize lives that are currently deemed ungrievable as worthy of recognition. |
|
23 |
+First, government officials in charge of nuclear power have structurally ignored the precarity of disenfranchised populations. Gamson |
|
24 |
+Gamson, William A. Talking Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1992. Print |
|
25 |
+The most prominent … utterances as well. |
|
26 |
+Analytic |
|
27 |
+Second, cultural stigma erases the violence imposed on individuals exposed to radiation. Cousins et al. |
|
28 |
+Cousins, Elicia, et al. "Nuclear Power and Environmental Justice." Carleton College, Environmental Studies Comprehensive Project Northfield, MN, USA |
|
29 |
+https://apps.carleton.edu/curricular/ents/assets/Cousins_Karban_Li_Zapanta.pdf |
|
30 |
+Another form of …explained after Chernobyl, |
|
31 |
+Third, nuclear power is dehumanizing. Johansen |
|
32 |
+A GLOBAL HUMANIST CRITIQUE OF NATIONAL POLICIES FOR ARMS CONTROL Author(s): Robert C. Johansen Source: Journal of International Affairs , Vol. 31, No. 2, The Future World Order (FALL/WINTER 1977), pp. 215-241 Published by: Journal of International Affairs Editorial Board Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/24367746 |
|
33 |
+Disarmament is also … arms control policies? |
|
34 |
+Analytic |
|
35 |
+Underview~-~-analytic |