Changes for page New Trier Tolan Aff

Last modified by Administrator on 2017/08/29 03:38

From version < 2.1 >
edited by Patrick Tolan
on 2016/11/10 02:11
To version < 31.1 >
edited by Patrick Tolan
on 2016/11/14 20:23
< >
Change comment: There is no comment for this version

Summary

Details

Caselist.RoundClass[0]
Cites
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +0
EntryDate
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,1 @@
1 -2016-11-10 02:11:35.470
1 +2016-11-10 02:26:08.0
Caselist.CitesClass[0]
Cites
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,62 @@
1 +====Status quo qualified immunity defense can only be defeated by a clearly established constitutional rights violation. This prioritizes law enforcement officials.====
2 +Hassel:
3 +Diana Hassel Winter 1999 Living a Lie: The Cost of Qualified Immunity Missouri Law Review http://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3402andcontext=mlr
4 +The threshold step in applying the qualified immunity defense is determining whether the facts the
5 +AND
6 +a way that decreases the amount of cases in which immunity is applicable.
7 +
8 +====My advocacy is that the United States ought to limit the scope of applicability for qualified immunity by removing the requirement of clear establishment for a constitutional violation.====
9 +Wright:
10 +Sam Wright (public interest lawyer) Nov. 3, 2015, "Want to Fight Police Misconduct? Reform Qualified Immunity." Above the Law http://abovethelaw.com/2015/11/want-to-fight-police-misconduct-reform-qualified-immunity/
11 +Instead, police officers have recourse to the broad protections of the judicially established doctrine
12 +AND
13 +to guaranteed civil and social rights.
14 +Prefer this for 2 additional reasons:
15 +====1. Procedural protections are necessary to promote rights. Even if we reform an imperfect system of procedural safeguards, we should change what we can to improve state accountability. ====
16 +Delgado explains:
17 +Richard, self-appointed Minority scholar, Chair of Law at the University of Alabama Law School, J.D. from the University of California, Berkeley, Professor Delgado's teaching and writing focus on race, the legal profession, and social change, 2009, "Does Critical Legal Studies Have What Minorities Want, Arguing about Law", p. 588-590
18 +
19 +The CLS critique
20 +AND
21 +what we want.
22 +
23 +====First, The clearly established requirement effectively denies individuals access to certain constitutional protections.====
24 +Hassel 2
25 +Diana Hassel Winter 1999 Living a Lie: The Cost of Qualified Immunity Missouri Law Review http://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3402andcontext=mlr (Balancing test is used in cases addressing due process of law)
26 +In some areas
27 +AND
28 + qualified immunity defense.
29 +====Reasonableness of inquiry questions stem from the clearly established requirement and give leeway to courts in siding with law enforcement. ====
30 +Hassel 3:
31 +Diana Hassel Winter 1999 Living a Lie: The Cost of Qualified Immunity Missouri Law Review http://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3402andcontext=mlr
32 +Finally, if the
33 +AND
34 +constitutional violation occurs.
35 +
36 +====Second, Qualified immunity allows for police officers to escape accountability for use of excessive force. ====
37 +Sheng writes: (Philip. Professor at BYU. An "Objectively Reasonable" Criticism of the Doctrine of Qualified Immunity in Excessive Force Cases Brought Under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, 26 BYU J. Pub. L. 99 Available at: http://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/jpl/vol26/iss1/5)
38 +In Graham v. Connor
39 +AND
40 + force cases altogether.
41 +
42 +====Ambiguous use of the clearly established requirement allows police officers to use excessive force with little deterrence or recourse. Qualified Immunity allows for the justification of violence. Both municipalities and individual police officers are unlikely to be found liable under current law. ====
43 +Senkel writes:
44 +1999 ( Tara. Attorney in New York. Civilians Often Need Protection From the Police: Let's Handcuff Police Brutality 15 N.Y.L. Sch. J. Hum. Rts. 385 (1998-1999). http://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?public=falseandhandle=hein.journals/nylshr15andpage=385andcollection=journals~~#)
45 +While victims of
46 +AND
47 +are exigent circumstances.237
48 +
49 +====Third, The clearly established requirement stands in the way of developing and protecting procedural rights. ====
50 +Attorneys only take on qualified immunity cases when there is little risk of losing the clearly established standard. Precedent can't evolve in the status quo because of selection bias.
51 +Reinert:
52 +Reinert, Alexander Does Qualified Immunity Matter? University of St. Thomas Law Journal. Volume 8 Spring 2011 (Interviews with 133 attorneys in qualified immunity cases)
53 +Nearly every respondent
54 +AND
55 + their organization's mission.
56 +
57 +
58 +====Thus, procedural protections cannot meaningfully exist in a world where plaintiffs must prove a clearly established violation. Only through removing the requirement can courts develop protections for individuals. Consideration of civil rights stagnates in a world where attorneys have disincentives to take the most controversial cases. ====
59 +Reinert 2:
60 +The data are
61 +AND
62 +qualified immunity defense.
EntryDate
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +2016-11-10 02:26:09.0
Judge
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +Mohamed, Aisha
Opponent
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +Lakeville North NG
ParentRound
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +0
Round
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +2
Team
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +New Trier Tolan Aff
Title
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +2 - Clearly Established AC
Tournament
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +Apple Valley
Caselist.CitesClass[3]
Cites
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,38 @@
1 +Hassel 2
2 +Diana Hassel Winter 1999 Living a Lie: The Cost of Qualified Immunity Missouri Law Review http://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3402andcontext=mlr (Balancing test is used in cases addressing due process of law)
3 +In some areas
4 +AND
5 + qualified immunity defense.
6 +====Reasonableness of inquiry questions stem from the clearly established requirement and give leeway to courts in siding with law enforcement. ====
7 +Hassel 3:
8 +Diana Hassel Winter 1999 Living a Lie: The Cost of Qualified Immunity Missouri Law Review http://scholarship.law.missouri.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3402andcontext=mlr
9 +Finally, if the
10 +AND
11 +constitutional violation occurs.
12 +
13 +====Second, Qualified immunity allows for police officers to escape accountability for use of excessive force. ====
14 +Sheng writes: (Philip. Professor at BYU. An "Objectively Reasonable" Criticism of the Doctrine of Qualified Immunity in Excessive Force Cases Brought Under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, 26 BYU J. Pub. L. 99 Available at: http://digitalcommons.law.byu.edu/jpl/vol26/iss1/5)
15 +In Graham v. Connor
16 +AND
17 + force cases altogether.
18 +
19 +====Ambiguous use of the clearly established requirement allows police officers to use excessive force with little deterrence or recourse. Qualified Immunity allows for the justification of violence. Both municipalities and individual police officers are unlikely to be found liable under current law. ====
20 +Senkel writes:
21 +1999 ( Tara. Attorney in New York. Civilians Often Need Protection From the Police: Let's Handcuff Police Brutality 15 N.Y.L. Sch. J. Hum. Rts. 385 (1998-1999). http://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?public=falseandhandle=hein.journals/nylshr15andpage=385andcollection=journals~~#)
22 +While victims of
23 +AND
24 +are exigent circumstances.237
25 +
26 +====Third, The clearly established requirement stands in the way of developing and protecting procedural rights. ====
27 +Attorneys only take on qualified immunity cases when there is little risk of losing the clearly established standard. Precedent can't evolve in the status quo because of selection bias.
28 +Reinert:
29 +Reinert, Alexander Does Qualified Immunity Matter? University of St. Thomas Law Journal. Volume 8 Spring 2011 (Interviews with 133 attorneys in qualified immunity cases)
30 +Nearly every respondent
31 +AND
32 + their organization's mission.
33 +
34 +====Thus, procedural protections cannot meaningfully exist in a world where plaintiffs must prove a clearly established violation. Only through removing the requirement can courts develop protections for individuals. Consideration of civil rights stagnates in a world where attorneys have disincentives to take the most controversial cases. ====
35 +Reinert 2:
36 +The data are
37 +AND
38 +qualified immunity defense.
EntryDate
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +2016-11-10 03:11:23.0
Judge
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +Kuang, Rebecca
Opponent
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +North Atlanta AM
ParentRound
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +3
Round
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +6
Team
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +New Trier Tolan Aff
Title
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +2- Clearly Established AC V3
Tournament
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +Apple Valley
Caselist.CitesClass[4]
Cites
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +My name is Patrick Tolan. Contact me Patrick@tolan3.com for cites or what have you. If you need to find me at a tournament talk to anyone from New Trier (debaters, coaches, or that guy with the backwards baseball hat) and you should be able to find me.
EntryDate
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +2016-11-10 21:36:03.0
Judge
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +hmmm
Opponent
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +hmmm
ParentRound
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +4
Round
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +Finals
Team
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +New Trier Tolan Aff
Title
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +0-Contact Info
Tournament
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +Contact
Caselist.RoundClass[3]
Cites
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +3
EntryDate
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +2016-11-10 03:11:21.0
Judge
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +Kuang, Rebecca
Opponent
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +North Atlanta AM
Round
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +6
RoundReport
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,2 @@
1 +1AC- Clearly Established
2 +1NC- Black Nihilism K Court Clog DA
Tournament
... ... @@ -1,0 +1,1 @@
1 +Apple Valley

Schools

Aberdeen Central (SD)
Acton-Boxborough (MA)
Albany (CA)
Albuquerque Academy (NM)
Alief Taylor (TX)
American Heritage Boca Delray (FL)
American Heritage Plantation (FL)
Anderson (TX)
Annie Wright (WA)
Apple Valley (MN)
Appleton East (WI)
Arbor View (NV)
Arcadia (CA)
Archbishop Mitty (CA)
Ardrey Kell (NC)
Ashland (OR)
Athens (TX)
Bainbridge (WA)
Bakersfield (CA)
Barbers Hill (TX)
Barrington (IL)
BASIS Mesa (AZ)
BASIS Scottsdale (AZ)
BASIS Silicon (CA)
Beckman (CA)
Bellarmine (CA)
Benjamin Franklin (LA)
Benjamin N Cardozo (NY)
Bentonville (AR)
Bergen County (NJ)
Bettendorf (IA)
Bingham (UT)
Blue Valley Southwest (KS)
Brentwood (CA)
Brentwood Middle (CA)
Bridgewater-Raritan (NJ)
Bronx Science (NY)
Brophy College Prep (AZ)
Brown (KY)
Byram Hills (NY)
Byron Nelson (TX)
Cabot (AR)
Calhoun Homeschool (TX)
Cambridge Rindge (MA)
Canyon Crest (CA)
Canyon Springs (NV)
Cape Fear Academy (NC)
Carmel Valley Independent (CA)
Carpe Diem (NJ)
Cedar Park (TX)
Cedar Ridge (TX)
Centennial (ID)
Centennial (TX)
Center For Talented Youth (MD)
Cerritos (CA)
Chaminade (CA)
Chandler (AZ)
Chandler Prep (AZ)
Chaparral (AZ)
Charles E Smith (MD)
Cherokee (OK)
Christ Episcopal (LA)
Christopher Columbus (FL)
Cinco Ranch (TX)
Citrus Valley (CA)
Claremont (CA)
Clark (NV)
Clark (TX)
Clear Brook (TX)
Clements (TX)
Clovis North (CA)
College Prep (CA)
Collegiate (NY)
Colleyville Heritage (TX)
Concord Carlisle (MA)
Concordia Lutheran (TX)
Connally (TX)
Coral Glades (FL)
Coral Science (NV)
Coral Springs (FL)
Coppell (TX)
Copper Hills (UT)
Corona Del Sol (AZ)
Crandall (TX)
Crossroads (CA)
Cupertino (CA)
Cy-Fair (TX)
Cypress Bay (FL)
Cypress Falls (TX)
Cypress Lakes (TX)
Cypress Ridge (TX)
Cypress Springs (TX)
Cypress Woods (TX)
Dallastown (PA)
Davis (CA)
Delbarton (NJ)
Derby (KS)
Des Moines Roosevelt (IA)
Desert Vista (AZ)
Diamond Bar (CA)
Dobson (AZ)
Dougherty Valley (CA)
Dowling Catholic (IA)
Dripping Springs (TX)
Dulles (TX)
duPont Manual (KY)
Dwyer (FL)
Eagle (ID)
Eastside Catholic (WA)
Edgemont (NY)
Edina (MN)
Edmond North (OK)
Edmond Santa Fe (OK)
El Cerrito (CA)
Elkins (TX)
Enloe (NC)
Episcopal (TX)
Evanston (IL)
Evergreen Valley (CA)
Ferris (TX)
Flintridge Sacred Heart (CA)
Flower Mound (TX)
Fordham Prep (NY)
Fort Lauderdale (FL)
Fort Walton Beach (FL)
Freehold Township (NJ)
Fremont (NE)
Frontier (MO)
Gabrielino (CA)
Garland (TX)
George Ranch (TX)
Georgetown Day (DC)
Gig Harbor (WA)
Gilmour (OH)
Glenbrook South (IL)
Gonzaga Prep (WA)
Grand Junction (CO)
Grapevine (TX)
Green Valley (NV)
Greenhill (TX)
Guyer (TX)
Hamilton (AZ)
Hamilton (MT)
Harker (CA)
Harmony (TX)
Harrison (NY)
Harvard Westlake (CA)
Hawken (OH)
Head Royce (CA)
Hebron (TX)
Heights (MD)
Hendrick Hudson (NY)
Henry Grady (GA)
Highland (UT)
Highland (ID)
Hockaday (TX)
Holy Cross (LA)
Homewood Flossmoor (IL)
Hopkins (MN)
Houston Homeschool (TX)
Hunter College (NY)
Hutchinson (KS)
Immaculate Heart (CA)
Independent (All)
Interlake (WA)
Isidore Newman (LA)
Jack C Hays (TX)
James Bowie (TX)
Jefferson City (MO)
Jersey Village (TX)
John Marshall (CA)
Juan Diego (UT)
Jupiter (FL)
Kapaun Mount Carmel (KS)
Kamiak (WA)
Katy Taylor (TX)
Keller (TX)
Kempner (TX)
Kent Denver (CO)
King (FL)
Kingwood (TX)
Kinkaid (TX)
Klein (TX)
Klein Oak (TX)
Kudos College (CA)
La Canada (CA)
La Costa Canyon (CA)
La Jolla (CA)
La Reina (CA)
Lafayette (MO)
Lake Highland (FL)
Lake Travis (TX)
Lakeville North (MN)
Lakeville South (MN)
Lamar (TX)
LAMP (AL)
Law Magnet (TX)
Langham Creek (TX)
Lansing (KS)
LaSalle College (PA)
Lawrence Free State (KS)
Layton (UT)
Leland (CA)
Leucadia Independent (CA)
Lexington (MA)
Liberty Christian (TX)
Lincoln (OR)
Lincoln (NE)
Lincoln East (NE)
Lindale (TX)
Livingston (NJ)
Logan (UT)
Lone Peak (UT)
Los Altos (CA)
Los Osos (CA)
Lovejoy (TX)
Loyola (CA)
Loyola Blakefield (MA)
Lynbrook (CA)
Maeser Prep (UT)
Mannford (OK)
Marcus (TX)
Marlborough (CA)
McClintock (AZ)
McDowell (PA)
McNeil (TX)
Meadows (NV)
Memorial (TX)
Millard North (NE)
Millard South (NE)
Millard West (NE)
Millburn (NJ)
Milpitas (CA)
Miramonte (CA)
Mission San Jose (CA)
Monsignor Kelly (TX)
Monta Vista (CA)
Montclair Kimberley (NJ)
Montgomery (TX)
Monticello (NY)
Montville Township (NJ)
Morris Hills (NJ)
Mountain Brook (AL)
Mountain Pointe (AZ)
Mountain View (CA)
Mountain View (AZ)
Murphy Middle (TX)
NCSSM (NC)
New Orleans Jesuit (LA)
New Trier (IL)
Newark Science (NJ)
Newburgh Free Academy (NY)
Newport (WA)
North Allegheny (PA)
North Crowley (TX)
North Hollywood (CA)
Northland Christian (TX)
Northwood (CA)
Notre Dame (CA)
Nueva (CA)
Oak Hall (FL)
Oakwood (CA)
Okoboji (IA)
Oxbridge (FL)
Oxford (CA)
Pacific Ridge (CA)
Palm Beach Gardens (FL)
Palo Alto Independent (CA)
Palos Verdes Peninsula (CA)
Park Crossing (AL)
Peak to Peak (CO)
Pembroke Pines (FL)
Pennsbury (PA)
Phillips Academy Andover (MA)
Phoenix Country Day (AZ)
Pine Crest (FL)
Pingry (NJ)
Pittsburgh Central Catholic (PA)
Plano East (TX)
Polytechnic (CA)
Presentation (CA)
Princeton (NJ)
Prosper (TX)
Quarry Lane (CA)
Raisbeck-Aviation (WA)
Rancho Bernardo (CA)
Randolph (NJ)
Reagan (TX)
Richardson (TX)
Ridge (NJ)
Ridge Point (TX)
Riverside (SC)
Robert Vela (TX)
Rosemount (MN)
Roseville (MN)
Round Rock (TX)
Rowland Hall (UT)
Royse City (TX)
Ruston (LA)
Sacred Heart (MA)
Sacred Heart (MS)
Sage Hill (CA)
Sage Ridge (NV)
Salado (TX)
Salpointe Catholic (AZ)
Sammamish (WA)
San Dieguito (CA)
San Marino (CA)
SandHoke (NC)
Santa Monica (CA)
Sarasota (FL)
Saratoga (CA)
Scarsdale (NY)
Servite (CA)
Seven Lakes (TX)
Shawnee Mission East (KS)
Shawnee Mission Northwest (KS)
Shawnee Mission South (KS)
Shawnee Mission West (KS)
Sky View (UT)
Skyline (UT)
Smithson Valley (TX)
Southlake Carroll (TX)
Sprague (OR)
St Agnes (TX)
St Andrews (MS)
St Francis (CA)
St James (AL)
St Johns (TX)
St Louis Park (MN)
St Margarets (CA)
St Marys Hall (TX)
St Thomas (MN)
St Thomas (TX)
Stephen F Austin (TX)
Stoneman Douglas (FL)
Stony Point (TX)
Strake Jesuit (TX)
Stratford (TX)
Stratford Independent (CA)
Stuyvesant (NY)
Success Academy (NY)
Sunnyslope (AZ)
Sunset (OR)
Syosset (NY)
Tahoma (WA)
Talley (AZ)
Texas Academy of Math and Science (TX)
Thomas Jefferson (VA)
Thompkins (TX)
Timber Creek (FL)
Timothy Christian (NJ)
Tom C Clark (TX)
Tompkins (TX)
Torrey Pines (CA)
Travis (TX)
Trinity (KY)
Trinity Prep (FL)
Trinity Valley (TX)
Truman (PA)
Turlock (CA)
Union (OK)
Unionville (PA)
University High (CA)
University School (OH)
University (FL)
Upper Arlington (OH)
Upper Dublin (PA)
Valley (IA)
Valor Christian (CO)
Vashon (WA)
Ventura (CA)
Veritas Prep (AZ)
Vestavia Hills (AL)
Vincentian (PA)
Walla Walla (WA)
Walt Whitman (MD)
Warren (TX)
Wenatchee (WA)
West (UT)
West Ranch (CA)
Westford (MA)
Westlake (TX)
Westview (OR)
Westwood (TX)
Whitefish Bay (WI)
Whitney (CA)
Wilson (DC)
Winston Churchill (TX)
Winter Springs (FL)
Woodlands (TX)
Woodlands College Park (TX)
Wren (SC)
Yucca Valley (CA)